2012 — Chris Wondolowski, San Jose
2011 — Dwayne De Rosario, D.C.
2010 — David Ferreira, Dallas
2009 — Landon Donovan, Los Angeles
2008 — Guillermo Barros Schelotto, Columbus
2007 — Luciano Emilio, D.C.
2006 — Christian Gomez, D.C.
2005 — Taylor Twellman, New England
2004 — Amado Guevara, MetroStars
2003 — Preki Radosavljevic, Kansas City
2002 — Carlos Ruiz, Los Angeles
2001 — Alex Pineda Chacon, Miami
2000 — Tony Meola, Kansas City
1999 — Jason Kreis, Dallas
1998 — Marco Etcheverry, D.C.
1997 — Preki Radosavljevic, Kansas City
1996 — Carlos Valderrama, Tampa Bay
