Print
Email
Share

Alaska lawmaker refuses Sea-Tac airport pat-down

by GLENN FARLEY / KING 5 News Aviation Specialist

KING5.com

Posted on February 21, 2011 at 7:41 AM

Updated Monday, Feb 21 at 7:33 PM

SEATTLE -- At one of Sea-Tac International Airport's TSA checkpoints an Alaska state representative drew the line. 

Rep. Sharon Cissna, a Democrat from Anchorage, is now making her way through Canada without traveling on an airplane.

Aftergoing through a body scanner at Sea-Tac over the weekend, which her office says she did not object to, Rep. Cissna was selected for a physical pat down. She had been in Seattle for medical treatment.

According to a statement released Sunday night by her chief of staff, Cissna is a cancer survivor, and underwent a mastectomy, which her office believes triggered that pat down. A pat down that Cissna refused, and she was not allowed to board her flight.  

Monday on the floor of the Alaska House of Representatives, a Republican colleague Alan Dick applauded her decision.

"I would like to honor our representative from Disttric 22 who is not here today, who chose to maintain her honor and her dignity and experience an inconvenience and discomfort and...my hope is that everyone of us would take an equal stand, a similar stand anytime we feel anytime we feel govt is being invasive and intrusive," said Rep. Dick.

The TSA triggered a national firestorm in recent months when it widely rolled out body scanners across the nation, including at Sea-Tac last year. 

The scanners set off health concerns because they use low level x-rays, and raised privacy objections because of the revealing images of people's bodies that are sent to a TSA screener in a windowless room. 

The TSA argues that privacy is protected because no screener can see faces in the images, and they never see the passenger. 

But the new physical pat downs that involve TSA screeners having to check passengers, even near their genital areas, has triggered perhaps a bigger backlash.

Washington's Senator Maria Cantwell, who is now head of the Senate Aviation Subcomittee, says there needs to be more options.

"We're going to continue to make improvements in security, but we have to take into account, that passengers can have a choice in this fashon. and certainly they do today," Sen. Cantwell said. 

The TSA did not elaborate on any specifics of the incident but said while it is sensitive to passenger concerns it must balance those concerns with the very real threat of someone trying to bring explosives aboard a plane.

Print
Email
Share
 

To add a comment, please register or login.

1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Comments: Displaying 1 - 15 of 32

walice said on February 25, 2011 at 12:40 PM

To make all happy, could or should we have different flights, " Flights with security checks" and "ones with lax security checks"?? If you choose lax security, you sign a waiver holding the airlines free of any harm resulting from. Of course, we still have the flying into buildings, etc. problem. Maybe most people would choose security, making the planes with lax security too small to do as much damage as big planes. Could we find pilots, stewards and etc. to work these lax flights? Hmmmm, problem still not solved, but a thought.

61413622
Flag this comment

kameha said on February 22, 2011 at 2:04 PM

another example of nazi america where you only live by their rules and do what they say or you are treated as a crimianl; freedom is dead.

61156099
Flag this comment

hourforum said on February 22, 2011 at 10:31 AM

Thank you but no I do not work for TSA nor any family. TSA does have it's place. But, I think that what TSA does goes way overboard on many things. Yes I like security at the airport- and on flights. I just do not think it is fair for them to frisk all of us, yet cargo goes unchecked. Yes we have come a long way since 9 11, but its time to relax some I think

61136184
Flag this comment

oneski said on February 22, 2011 at 9:56 AM

A simple ID check and they'd know she was an Alaskan lawmaker and not a terrorist. I consider this harrassment and I don't feel safer at all, only more "threatened" by my own government!

61132948
Flag this comment

freedomthinker said on February 22, 2011 at 8:59 AM

the government has an interest in keeping us secureD, not the same as secure.

61127863
Flag this comment

glock2117 said on February 22, 2011 at 7:43 AM

hourforum either works for TSA or has a relative cause yes they are a joke but everyone needs to stop blaming TSA for these decisions its obama and other elected officials who direct them and approve what they do so remember that people in 2012 our entire government needs to be changed up these same faces over and over in our senate and congress for 20 years thats the same idiots making stupid decisions during clinton bush and obama

61121734
Flag this comment

badbannedben said on February 22, 2011 at 4:51 AM

TSA = idiots. WTF do they think they are accomplishing by forcing an elected lawmaker with a mastechtomy to a pat down? That is as DUMB as a pile of rocks. TSA has no idea what they are doing. I've flown plenty in and out of Israel and love the training and professionalism of all Israeli agent who screen every passenger on every flight in and out of Israel. There are right ways and wrong ways and what we ended up is beyond wrong - it's STUPID wrong... It's embarrasing to be an American sometimes...

61113179
Flag this comment

kingcountryvoter said on February 22, 2011 at 12:47 AM

Good job Gov. TSA is a wasted of taxpayer money and needs to be reigned it. I hope you started the snowball. Thank you

61109028
Flag this comment

hourforum said on February 21, 2011 at 8:22 PM

TSA is not a joke. Those who demanded that our personal bodys 'might" be carrying someting maybe we should not is something else. I like everyone likes to fly with security, being safe. the problem is that TSA does not screen cargo the way it should. Every passenger is screeed. Now the lawmaker here ROFL. Please! Chance are she voted FOR the TSA under Bush. I think the TSA its self should relax quite a bit.

61098518
Flag this comment

scott_bellevue said on February 21, 2011 at 8:21 PM

@lsmith5870400119 I don't want to work for you, so I won't take your silly drug test. I won't work for anyone that treats me like a criminal. And I don't want to live in a country that so regularly treats its citizens like criminals. Therefore it my right and duty as an American to stand up and say no, and not live like a sheep. If you want sheep working for you, go for it. I live free, and stand tall like a real man.

61098493
Flag this comment

s10maniac said on February 21, 2011 at 7:51 PM

Way to go Alaska Governer!!! I am very proud.

61096718
Flag this comment

s10maniac said on February 21, 2011 at 7:50 PM

The TSA is a joke. Way more planes go down because of Mechanical issues or pilot error. There are very few planes taken down by terrorists. Flying is way safer than driving so invest those TSA dollars in more police and better roads. Why can't they just use metal detectors and bomb sniffing dogs? I would trust a dog much better than that scanner.

61096658
Flag this comment

skippythedog said on February 21, 2011 at 6:40 PM

Ya wanna ride the boat? Fine, ride the boat...Great example you're setting. What government do you work for again?

61091718
Flag this comment

idahoreader said on February 21, 2011 at 5:53 PM

Safety first. People are trying to kill us by smuggling bombs on board. I now will not fly, but if I had to, I would want a careful search of EVERYONE that boards the plane. Hey folks, there are those that are trying to KILL us. We Have to be careful.

61088588
Flag this comment

susanp59 said on February 21, 2011 at 4:40 PM

Last week while attending the Golf show at Qwest Field I was very surprised to see that our taxes had paid for the TSA to have a booth in the show. Really at a golf show? There were 5 TSA employees in the booth all wearing the official blue uniform along with their phony badges. As I approached the booth one of the TSA employees was in the face of a middle aged man. As I stood and listened to the exchange I realized that the citizen had asked the TSA employee if he could list just one terrorist incident that the TSA had been able to stop at a US airport using any of these ridiculous search techniques. The TSA employee claimed that the TSA had stopped the shoe bomber even though as everyone knows the show bomber was stopped by the passengers on the plane over the Atlantic Ocean. When he was challenged on his shoe bomber claim he verbally began to attack this man I am sure in the same way that this lady was verbally attacked at SEA-TAC. Enough is Enough!

61083183
Flag this comment

akrandy said on February 21, 2011 at 3:29 PM

Seem TSA is willing to stereo type people if they are woman that have had a mastectomy

61077848
Flag this comment

nite_riderusa said on February 21, 2011 at 3:18 PM

I applaud this woman for taking a stand. The fact is, It has beenNON AMERICAN MALE MUSLIM MEN who have hijacked and rammed our planes into buildings. Not FEMALE STATE LEGISLATORS from ALASKA! Can you hear me TSA !!@!?? This is one area where sterotyping would work.

61076883
Flag this comment

canadianson said on February 21, 2011 at 2:49 PM

I will not fly due to these measures. I find them to be intusive and unconstitutional. Illegal search. When we as a country decide we are tired of having our rights stripped away it will change. The loss of revenue to the airlines by the folks who refuse to fly will only help end this invasion of privacy.

61074218
Flag this comment

commentariette said on February 21, 2011 at 2:07 PM

There are nearly 3m breast cancer survivors in the US; some 2% of adult women. The nation's security (and economy) are hardly improved by forcing these women to choose between invasive and humiliating searches of their mutilated bodies and hiding themselves at home. Congratulations to Rep. Cissna for taking a stand -- I'll be sending a letter of support! I hope this also leads to organizations like the American Cancer Society and Susan G Komen taking a stand! I'll be contacting them, too.

61070857
Flag this comment

mlloyd said on February 21, 2011 at 12:06 PM

I will step through the normal magnetic scanner but I will not step into the body scanner because the government lies to us and I simply don't trust them to tell us the truth on that scanner. Ten year from now, we will find out that they were not as safe as they said they were. They can feel me out and touch my junk until the cows come home, but they can take their scanner and stuff it where the sun doesn't shine.

61060038
Flag this comment

siusir said on February 21, 2011 at 11:12 AM

TSA is useless as are these so-called measures to ensure our safety on flights. Way to go, pat her down for having a mastectomy. Yeah, I may seem unfair to TSA.

61054657
Flag this comment

phil101 said on February 21, 2011 at 10:57 AM

Seriously people? I flew from Spokane to Seattle last Monday, and surprisingly, something on my hands triggered a sensor on their little machine. TSA employees quietly and respectfully asked if I could step aside and have a further search. I was shocked because I fly quite often, and have never had this problem. However, it's part of their job to do this, and I'm sure they enjoy it about as much as we as passengers do. There are parts of my job that I dislike, and parts that an outsider would question/dislike, but that's how things go. After being patted down (the older female TSA agent was very respectful while doing this, explained everything as she was doing it, and in no way "invaded or groped" my body), yes, I was surprised and a little embarrassed, but again, they are JUST DOING THEIR JOB. And while I have a more-than-sensitive outlook for breast cancer survivors (my mother included) I don't think this particular person is being realistic or patriotic at all in her actions.

61053288
Flag this comment

2cents said on February 21, 2011 at 10:55 AM

Wow, I'm sure she wants the TSA agents to see that she's had her boob chopped off because of cancer! Then have some stranger poking their hands around the missing piece of flesh? Sound crude? It is, but what does it take to wake up to the fact that we have to give away our rights to travel? I know, I know, we can stay at home or take the boat. But flying is the normal and standard form of transportation toady and we should be free to use it with reasonable expectation.

61053113
Flag this comment

lsmith5870400119 said on February 21, 2011 at 10:51 AM

scott_bellevue If you want to fly, live with the rules. If you want to work for me and I require a drug test, you will take it or not work. Your choice. Why would anyone want a bunch of crank heads working for them?

61052658
Flag this comment

andyblue555 said on February 21, 2011 at 10:46 AM

Terrorists attack us ten years ago and we are the ones who are patted down by under paid under trained morons. Makes sense. I work at the airport but wont fly since I have seen exactly what and who is rubbing thier hands all over your privates. Most of these agents are on a power trip and think they own you and your body until you get past their screen stations. They Love touching you.

61052103
Flag this comment

slappywag said on February 21, 2011 at 10:09 AM

banditrider, you are a paranoid schizophrenic and should seek some professional help. NOBOBY is out to get you. The likelihood that you would ever be directly involved in something to do with terrorism is so remote it isn't funny. You are doing exactly what they want you to do. Panic for no reason. Just like sensational articles in the 'news'. People like YOU that want to be safe at the cost of your freedoms are buffoons. Me? I refuse to fly until they remove all of the garbage pat downs, body scans, the TSA screwing with you at every possible juncture, and the ASSUMPTION that I am doing something wrong. This goes against every value that ALL Americans should have. You're a sellout and do not deserve the rights you have. People like you make me sick.

61048703
Flag this comment

shellycantrell said on February 21, 2011 at 10:04 AM

when will we learn most people traveling within the usa are not the problem it's the people coming into our country that seems to have cause this overboard type of security measures. i used to love to fly now i hate it cause of all the things we have to go through to travel..take off your shoes you can't carry on any toiletries in a carry on this is getting out of control even the military guys have been scutinized when traveling sorry to sound rude but it's not most american people we need to worry about.......just saying

61048288
Flag this comment

papabill said on February 21, 2011 at 9:51 AM

.Good for Sharon, if more of us would have the gumption to refuse, maybe this insanity will stop. I have personal friends that have been humiliated and mortified by this process. When are we going to restore sanity to our broken system. I for one am refusing to fly and will either drive, take the train (if you can find one that is going to your destination) or ride the bus. It is time to return to the friendly skies – where the concerns for and the comfort of the passenger are first and foremost. Our Airports have been desecrated and traveling is a nightmare. It is time to return to a more gracious time, where the traveling public it treated with respect.

61047043
Flag this comment

banditrider said on February 21, 2011 at 9:45 AM

I want to be safe on a plane, if you don't want a pat down, don't fly. This Alaska Rep. did the right thing. Didn't raise a big fuss and took the boat.

61046503
Flag this comment

scott_bellevue said on February 21, 2011 at 9:17 AM

Yes! We should all be refusing that pat down and body scanners. The terrorists won, and we now have a society we don't want to live in. We should all be refusing drug tests too. And we should all be forced to recite the 4th amendment every day until we remember what it means.

61044458
Flag this comment

davesea said on February 21, 2011 at 8:49 AM

The terrorist have won. They've caused the USA to spend billions of dollars on useless security measures and have created a vast government agency costing more billions. Their goal is to destroy this country, what better way then to destroy us then from within.

61041932
Flag this comment

underserf said on February 21, 2011 at 8:14 AM

Like everyone else (apparently) in AK, she was packing heat. Since aircraft are private resources, no one has the right to demand their service. Put up with their requirements or take a bus.

61039128
Flag this comment