Print
Email
Share

State investigates Seattle Children's after boy is paralyzed

by KING 5 News

KING5.com

Posted on October 7, 2010 at 6:02 PM

Updated Thursday, Oct 7 at 11:11 PM

SEATTLE – Three new investigations are now open into a case at Seattle Children's hospital involving a 2-year-old boy who is now brain damaged after surgery.

Osman Ali stares blankly at the world. He's fed every 90 minutes by a tube in his nose. His brain was permanently damaged after a heart operation at Children's in February. His father, Nasir, wrote a letter of complaint to the Washington state Department of Health and has been notified an investigation is underway.

"I think it's a step forward in finding some of the answers that we don't know at this time," said Nasir.

  • The DOH's Facilities and Services division is checking the hospital's procedures and policies.
  • The Medical Quality Assurance Commission will examine what doctors did.
  • The Nursing Care Quality Assurance Commission will do the same for the nursing staff.

No timeline is set, but it could be months before they're wrapped up.

Children's confirmed for the first time Thursday that the state has told them the case is under investigation.

Hospitals are required to report "adverse medical events" to the state. In Osman's case, Children's didn't make that report. In fact, it reported no "adverse events" in the first quarter of this year.

"I have been told that his artery was ruptured because of the balloon that was used. But why we don't know any of that," said Nasir.

But it is not clear that Children's had any responsibility to report this to the state. An artery burst by a balloon catheter during a procedure and resulting brain damage may not fit any of the 28 state definitions for "adverse medical event."

Nasir just hopes the attention on the case and the three investigations will give him some answers.

"I'm his voice. I'm only his voice. I'm the only voice he can get at this time," said Nasir.

The head of Seattle Children's cardiac catheterization labs says the procedure used on Osman is standard. It has about a two-percent chance of failure. He says he believes that the family was aware of the risks involved at the time. He adds that everybody involved is saddened by the outcome.

Seattle Children's has promised nursing care to Osman through the end of October.

KING 5's Allen Schauffler contributed to this report.

Print
Email
Share
 

To add a comment, please register or login.

1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Comments: Displaying 1 - 15 of 15

aleigha said on October 9, 2010 at 11:24 AM

@kbbcoop..that is EXACTLY the same question I asked the first time this article aired! WHAT ON EARTH DO THEY THINK 4 MEASLY MONTHS OF CARE is going to do when he needs 24/7 care for THE REST OF HIS LIFE!!!! What.. that's all they think they should be responsible for? They essentually "killed" this little guy and don't have a responsibility to take care of him?!!!! Sickening!!!!

53512207
Flag this comment

lovenotwar said on October 8, 2010 at 1:57 PM

WOW to you newsjunkie13.My intent was not to say that doctors had to be perfect or that I was expecting that whats so ever. In a perfect world that would be very nice. I clearly recongize that mistakes do happen,obviously in Children's case they have been making quite a few of them lately. If you even read what I had said," I understand they can't get it right every time and nothing is promised in this day and age". Why don't you read all of what is said before you start up sparking up a discusion. Great to know that you had a wonderful experiance at Children's, that's good for you and glad to know your child is health, that's what every parent wishes and prays for. But sadly, that wasn't the outcome for this family, or the 19 or so other families that have lost their chidren at that hospital. I am not leaving this comment to go at with you, that's not my style. But understand, 10 times the dosage of what a infant needs and death is the outcome is something we can not afford. God bless

53467388
Flag this comment

newsjunkie13 said on October 8, 2010 at 1:39 PM

Wow "lovenotwar," I wish I was as perfect as you and didn't make mistakes. I mean I went to college and learned how to do things too, but I still make mistakes. My son has been at Children's for many, many procedures and check-ups. He spent his first couple of months of life there and had the same procedure Osman had done. We knew the risks of having the procedure done on such a little guy, but also knew the information it could provide with the results. His procedure turned out fine and as a result we found out his heart was in better shape than was thought. My point is that Children's is a wonderful place and is the first place I would take any of my children. But you need to be your child's advocate and be involved in EVERYTHING. They invite you to be part of discussions when they do rounds - DO IT. Ask questions, lots of them. Don't be embarrassed to ask them to explain something in layman's terms. You might feel like you are being annoying, but who cares! This is your child!

53466249
Flag this comment

lovenotwar said on October 8, 2010 at 1:22 PM

I am so sorry to hear about this little boy! My heart, love, thoughts and prayers go out to the little boy and his family. I wish there was more I could do to help out the family in their time of need. I just want to bring to light that a very ill little girl was recently killed at Children Hospital because the nurse gave her 10 times the dosage of calcium that she needed. 10 times!?!? That is very odd and crazy to me! I understamd that they can't get it right every time and nothing is promised in this day and age, but isn't that why they pay good money to go to a good college? To practice their studies, before they perform them on real humans? What have they been doing this whole time? I mean, they have been going to school for years, are they just slipping by? I really hope not. I defintely am scared to bring my children (once I have them) to Children's.

53465177
Flag this comment

tacwilster said on October 8, 2010 at 9:49 AM

This is a very sad outcome but anytime a person, young or old, has surgery the doctors, nurses, hospitals can not guarantee a 100% recover. Is the state going to look into every hospital where a patient died or had adverse effects after a surgery?? Why are they picking on Childrens hospital? This is a wonderful hospital and yes tragedies happen but the good they do out weighs the bad.

53450592
Flag this comment

kbbcoop said on October 8, 2010 at 8:36 AM

"Seattle Children's has promised nursing care to Osman through the end of October." What happens at the end of October, he is miraculously cured? This poor kid is going to need nursing 24-7 for the rest of his life.

53444306
Flag this comment

loralovely87 said on October 8, 2010 at 7:13 AM

I ve never had anything but good experience with the childrens hospital theyve saved more lives than lost. But im just wandering whats been going on lately for so many mistakes to be happening in such a short time

53436656
Flag this comment

avianrescue said on October 7, 2010 at 11:12 PM

So sorry to hear all this and my prayers to the families. My son had three surgeries years ago there. All very successful. My experience with Children's has been wonderful.

53418489
Flag this comment

telman said on October 7, 2010 at 9:13 PM

Years ago my Grandmother told me stay out of hospital they may kill you. There may be some truth to that saying. I myself try to stay out as well as try to keep the kids healthy but alas sometimes we need them. Anytime surgery comes into play there is always risk of injury and death. My heart goes out to that poor child and his family.

53415314
Flag this comment

momoftwo9700 said on October 7, 2010 at 9:02 PM

That's why they have the parents/guardians sign a form that acknowledges the risks of a procedure. If you have been a nurse in the position of caring for a patient - you know the risks and the ups and downs. Sometimes it is difficult to discern the directions of a DR or the dosage for a particular med. In addition, if there is a risk, as there always is, it stinks, but it is real. I am so very sad for this family, however, it must be investigated thoroughly before an accusation is made.

53414944
Flag this comment

bazwest said on October 7, 2010 at 7:50 PM

What is this 'smear Children's hospital week'?! For pete's sake people operations are dangerous, they are risky, there is never a guaranteed positive outcome. Has anyone here ever witnessed the trauma that a little body has to withstand when open heart surgery is performed? All it takes is one little blood clot in the wrong place or an unexpected complication and a patient faces loss of functionality or even death. The hysteria, the unrealistic anger at doctors, the unrealistic expectation placed on doctors is a huge problem. This is why we have unnecessary lawsuits and medical costs are skyrocketing for all of us. Malpractice insurance often costs surgeon more per year than many of us make in total. Should we ban doctors from doing surgery because it is too risky? No! I think we all would want a skilled surgeon to give us a chance at a new lease on life if we truly needed it.

53412063
Flag this comment

greatwhitellama said on October 7, 2010 at 7:05 PM

Hospitals maim and kill more people than cars and firearms combined. With the influx of new patients as mandated by the 'health care overhaul', the number of victims will increase. Should we ban hospitals in the name of public health? :P

53409799
Flag this comment

ramac7716 said on October 7, 2010 at 7:04 PM

Remember all Doctors practices their trade

53409784
Flag this comment

yogibear said on October 7, 2010 at 6:44 PM

Before surgery is performed the parents must sign a document stating the risks involved. That document could be part of the outcome to this case.

53408812
Flag this comment

tugthug said on October 7, 2010 at 6:38 PM

Two deaths, one adult almost died and now this. This is way to many problems for a hospital in such a short time frame. The hospital states the parents new the risks? What kind of BS is that! The hospital needs to take responsiblilty and hold individuals accoutable for their actions! Nasir I would consider bringing a lawsuit.

53408554
Flag this comment