Share this article:
Print

Curt Knox calls guilty verdict 'travesty of justice'

Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

by LINDA BYRON / KING 5 News

Posted on December 5, 2009 at 6:37 PM

Updated Saturday, Dec 5 at 6:39 PM

******

PERUGIA, Italy - Amanda Knox's family had been hoping to bring her from Perugia to Seattle in time to celebrate Christmas. They were stunned by her conviction, but within hours had moved from sadness to anger, and were planning her appeal.

"This is a travesty of justice, and it needs to get fixed," said Amanda's father, Curt Knox.

"We had to kind of yell that we love her, and we could hear her when she left the door, literally break down," he said.

The Saturday headlines across Italy screamed out the news. Amanda Knox, guilty, condemned to spend 27 years locked behind bars.

Judgment day was harsh and swift. The jury spent just one day deliberating in a case that began with Amanda's arrest more than two years ago.

It was not the news the family was ready to hear.

"They didn't have the courage. They failed their legal system," said Curt Knox.

"We just lost it and we just broke down because we saw her crying and it just broke our hearts," said Amanda's 11-year-old sister, Delaney.

Mixed reaction as prison vans raced through the crowded streets. some onlookers cried; others yelled "assassin."

The shell-shocked Knox family fled through the streets of historic Perugia, pursued by relentless cameras.

But within hours they were at the Capanne prison, telling their daughter their plans for an appeal, encouraged that the jury didn't deliver the life sentence prosecutors were asking for, and by signs of political pressure at home.

"We will find a way," said Curt Knox. "She's not going to be left here alone. I mean it's just not going to happen and we'll do whatever it takes to bring her home."

The defense team is now waiting for the jury motivations. These are the explanations of how they reached their decision. But the Knox family has been warned it could be next September before the official appeals process would begin. By then Amanda would have been in prison for nearly three years.

Share this article:
Print

To add a comment, please register or login.

Leave your comment
1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

HTML is not allowed.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

lin1945 said on December 5, 2009 at 7:22 PM

I am honestly surprised that Mr. Knox, his family, Mrs. Huff and all of her family are so surprised at the verdict. If they had read the blogs, the news reports, sensed the mood in Italy, especially in Perugia, they would have realized and should have understood that the case was headed to a guilty verdict. Everytime one of the Knox family spoke out they did damage to the result as the jurors, as well as the two judges, could read, hear, disguss all aspects of the case and filter all the Knox family comments. Putting down Italy and the justice system only inflames the readers and puts pressure on the jurors to find Ms Knox guilty. If there Knox family had people working with them that had an understanding of the way the justice system works in Italy they should have understood LESS comments are much better. The bottom line is someone has to pay for the terrible murder, the facts in the Rudy Guede case indicates there were at least two participants and probably three. Better silence.

33171534
Flag this comment

graham said on December 5, 2009 at 7:26 PM

Well if the family does'nt like how the trial turned out then they should have kept the little brat out of trouble, but the rich think they can do what they want & money will get them out of trouble, now they need to put the parents behind bars for there big mouth.

33171634
Flag this comment

usfbullman said on December 5, 2009 at 9:07 PM

I can understand why the family feels the same way. I am not sure if I was put in thier position I would not feel the same way. I do not think they are helping thier case by blasting the italian courts. Its a first world country with a court system I belivie to be as fair as the united states. the evidence unfortunatly pointed to her guilt. Unless new evidence arises I seriously doubt going further into debt will do anything but further destroy this family

33174547
Flag this comment

brewster said on December 5, 2009 at 9:24 PM

Cope with it Kurt, your daughter took the life away from a young girl, she deserves worse than she is getting now!

33175079
Flag this comment

thirdparty said on December 5, 2009 at 10:52 PM

From what I heard on the news about Amanda's initial 14 hour interogation, she sealed her fate when she changed her story. Quote, "I was in the other room and cupped my ears." If she truly was in the other room, I can understand how scared she must have been for her own safety, I feel for all the families. I'm a human. I truly hope, at the appeal, the truth will prevail.

33177567
Flag this comment

lakerstyle said on December 5, 2009 at 11:21 PM

As hard as it is for Amanda knox's family to accept the verdict that the Italian Courts has handed down, truth be told...it is all but certain that Amanda knew what happened that fateful night to her roommate. Why, she even went as far as to implicate another person, who was later found not to be that person of interest. Her stories were always inconsistent. A truthful statement of facts are always the same...it doesn't change. I know she wishes it were all a dream...and she would wake up and find herself back home in Seatle,WA. She's fully aware of her guilt. The family of Meredith Kercher is still devastated even after (2) yrs. Amanda Knox should've come clean...she may not have taken part in the actual killing...but her actions after the incident points to her being an accessory to the crime. In short...Justice was served.

33178241
Flag this comment

honestahol said on December 6, 2009 at 2:29 AM

This is every parent's nightmare. Sending the kid to a foreign college for higher and broader education, only to hear she's just committed a murder, in the middle of some crazy@$$ sex game... Let's take a look at the bottom line. The bottom line is...it's Amanda's fault. She ruined it. And she's the one who drained their money. Stop blaming Italian law enforcement and justice system. If you still have to blame someone, then, blame yourselves. Since this country asserts freedom in religion, I'm not going to mention religion. But I want to ask all the parents to be good, moral citizens in front of your children at all time. Teach your children about morality and be strict about it. Once again, talk is cheap. You have to show your children you're a good role model always.

33181202
Flag this comment

huh_what said on December 6, 2009 at 2:30 AM

Foxy Knoxy is in a boxy where she belongs! How did she only get 26 years for slitting a throat? This entitled little brat thought she could get away with murder because she had bucks. Oh well, now she's in the slammer where she can rot. She prolly won't be foxy anymore in 26 years and her life won't be worth anything anymore.

33181216
Flag this comment

honestahol said on December 6, 2009 at 2:33 AM

Stop blaming Italian law enforcement and justice system. If you still have to blame someone, then, blame yourselves. Since this country asserts freedom in religion, I'm not going to mention religion. But I want to ask all the parents to be good, moral citizens in front of your children at all time. Teach your children about morality and be strict about it. Once again, talk is cheap. You have to show your children you're a good role model always.

33181244
Flag this comment

kenpomaster said on December 6, 2009 at 2:59 AM

Being a college student and all that, she should have been different from low-life thugs. Unfortunately, it turned out she's doing time for murder just like low-life thugs. So, she is, she was, and she has been a low-life after all. Just like everything in the world, the foundation is very important. Without that correct foundation, nothing really matters because it will collapse soon. Gee, I really miss the time when most people had strong sense of morality.

33181549
Flag this comment

skippythedog said on December 6, 2009 at 3:38 AM

Deal w/ it. She lied about her whereabouts and even implicated another person and then changed her story

33181957
Flag this comment

justcommenting said on December 6, 2009 at 4:46 AM

i do not understand why they were surprised. their kid killed another kid and was found guilty. end of story.

33182801
Flag this comment

emimacausbrybel said on December 6, 2009 at 6:51 AM

It is not your character or background that should determine a person's guilt! It should be concrete, absolute forensic evidence. That DID NOT happen here. She has been judged by her family's "wealth", the fact that she's American, her choice of friends, and statements she made under duress. If that is how any legal system convicts people, they should be ashamed!

33185841
Flag this comment

browndog said on December 6, 2009 at 8:52 AM

does anybody care about Amanda Knox anymore, she is a criminal from the get go, yeah their justice system screwed some things up but she is still guilty of a crime lets move on this is a horrible top story every day.

33190524
Flag this comment

jpalla said on December 6, 2009 at 8:55 AM

Every country in the world has a differet Justice system. As a father myself I can understand that Amanda's Father is so defensive to protect his daughter any father or mother would. But he also needs to step back and take a real world look at his daughter she maybe the apple of his eye but children as they grow make different choices of what they want to do. and as one veiwer said she may not have done the crime but I feel she has more information of what happen then she is saying. And having been to Italy before I know if the parents continue belittling there justice system and continue to get politacal pressure applied to Italy like what I heard from Maria Cantwell well I hate to say it but the police will find her dead one morning in her cell. She will have her appeal process but everyone needs to step back and let it work. She may have to spend 26years in jail but stop belittling another countries justice bsystem because the verdict didn't go there way

33190722
Flag this comment

bigdon said on December 6, 2009 at 10:56 AM

Nothing good can come from a combination of promiscuity, alcohol, drugs, and Nigerians.

33196629
Flag this comment

vietvet said on December 6, 2009 at 11:45 AM

I can't believe a "spoiled brat" sells more papers with headlines of her exploits in Italy, then the loss of 4 puplic servants. To me, it makes me want to puke. How can the news media thrive on this "spoiled brat" and her families displeasure and money problems, when we should be focusing on helping 4 families in a very difficult time. These 4 officers were not partying, playing sex games etc., they were trying to help our community and they are brushed aside by headlines and stories of the "spoiled brat". I guess s^#t is what sells the news.

33198894
Flag this comment

hippiegirl said on December 6, 2009 at 12:38 PM

Mr. Knox: I'm sorry your daughter is in the situation she is in, but she has been found guilty. Your daughter will have to pay the price for what she did. At least she has her life and can go free in 26 years. Meredith Kercher's family has to suffer endlessly for what your daughter did. They cannot visit their daughter EVER. And in 26 years they will still be without their daughter ALWAYS. Your daughter made poor choices. Everyone does, but not to the extreme your daughter did.

33200466
Flag this comment

goodsama said on December 6, 2009 at 1:34 PM

i love how we in this country have convicted this young woman from the start...we look at her families supposed wealth(they are actually middle class and deeply in debt) and use that to assassinate her family with our comments.....the truth is none of us here know what really happened. we know a sick crime was committed and we want to assume regardless of whether its in italy or here that the person arrested is responsible but in this case...we must not forget that the prosecutor in this case is under investigation in italy for severe misconduct. he has made inflammatory statements to the press that have been anti american to say the least. he puts himself off as power and press hungry and is up for re election....the case was built on flimsy circumstantial evidence and the crime scene was destroyed and messed with....a bad crime was comitted in small town italy the prosecutor had to nail some one...who better than a pretty american study abroad college student...

33202034
Flag this comment

billiameveryman said on December 6, 2009 at 4:23 PM

I normally loathe the "race card" but I also wonder what the reaction would be if Amanda Knox was a young black woman from Detroit? Would the assumptions of innocence still be as immediate? It would seem to me that if this trial had happened in America, Knox would have walked, not because she is innocent, but because our legal system is skewed to find "technicalities" for people of certain statuses (race being one, but also, and more importantly, wealth, sex also factors in of course...) to avoid true justice ...

33207712
Flag this comment

gertie_cat said on December 6, 2009 at 5:13 PM

"A sentence that seems as medieval as ancient Perugia itself" . Really, Linda Byron? Really? 26 years imprisonment for murder is a medieval sentence? I'd say that Know is getting off pretty light for being found guilty.

33209476
Flag this comment

riff_raff said on December 6, 2009 at 5:32 PM

I'm so glad this 2-year ordeal is finally over and perhaps we can all move on with our lives in the news media. Amanda is a true actress of Dr. Jeckell & Mr. Hyde. Her false portrayal of a sweet innocent girl failed and the jury saw right thru her evil plans. Amanda must be exhausted by this failed attempt at her innocence, but she'll have the next 26 years to catch-up on her sleep. I hope Amanda enjoyed her brief love fling with her boyfriend, because she won't sleep with another man until she's almost 50. I guess in the interim, she'll become a lesbian with her cell-mates. Her new full name is: Amanda "School Of Hard" Knox.

33210132
Flag this comment

sufferingmom said on December 6, 2009 at 5:46 PM

I am a grandmother of 2 both girls and adults. I think the american people should start a donation of only one dollar each, and we could help this girls family . Maybe our country can do something to help get her out of prison, if we all pull together. Just imagine if that was your daughter, grandaughter or sister or mom, what would you do to help get them home? I do not think this girl is guilty of such a crime, and beleive there are enough mothers, and grandmothers, out there that would help . I would start a web site if i could. Please consider helping this girl, she is innocent in my eyes.

33210554
Flag this comment

billiameveryman said on December 6, 2009 at 6:34 PM

Suffering mom, you think she is innocent because she is a girl... Times have changed, and women are now just as capable of violent crimes as men... Your donations should go to the family who had their daughter savagely sexually assaulted and murdered...

33212281
Flag this comment

motherofinnocent said on December 6, 2009 at 6:40 PM

I would like to know why my comments were deleted from your article?

33212492
Flag this comment

ladymarch24 said on December 6, 2009 at 6:41 PM

I am very surprised at the hateful comments left by the previous writers. I am not convinced that Amanda Knox and her boy friend murdered her roommate. The Italian justice system, including the prosecutor, has received notorious publicity about the flamboyant procedures they use to prosecute those accused. I am convinced that the Rudy Guede was the actual murderer, and he is now serving his time. The naivete of Amanda Knox is obvious. Her family is not rich, but they allowed this spoiled young lady to have her way and go to Italy to study. However, like so many young students, she got caught up in the loose lifestyle of Italy, and now is paying the conquences. I would never allow my children to study in Europe until I had made a full investigation of what really goes on in the chosen country. My heart goes out to the victims family in England. I just do not think that Amanda is the murderer of their daughter. May God bless the Knox family and the family of the victim .

33212539
Flag this comment

thirdparty said on December 6, 2009 at 7:25 PM

We all have analytic minds and are prone to wanting to find out the truth in every situation. It puts our hearts and mind at peace to have the final piece of the puzzle. We need to look at every angle outside the box. I think there is more to this situation than what meets the eye. ie...The clue is fear of the most powerful head of the justice system. We cannot stop analyzing yet. Amanda and Raffaelle could really be innocent. Whats Meredith's background? She dosent look like a anglel in the picture they choose to show of her.Here picture portrays her as a vixon. Maybe she brought three guys home from the bar. Maybe Rudy was jealous,because she didn't want anything to do with him...and I don't blame her. Yah shes dead but that happens all the time to loose girls everywhere. Amanda and Raffaele were enjoying each others company. A perfect set up to blame them for the crime. Don't be so quick to judge with your hateful comments. They truly could be innocent!!

33213864
Flag this comment

lakerstyle said on December 6, 2009 at 7:54 PM

RE: goodsama's comment This country did not convict Amanda Knox. The evidence presented to the jury in her case, by Italy's court system convicted her. The jury had a right to accept or reject the evidence. Amanda lost her "American" good girl status, when she made a conscience decision to date a loser boyfriend and befriend a career criminal...share drugs and alcohol, engage in sexual misconduct, and ultimately torture to death a young woman of her peer. To take part in such an act of devilish proportion clearly demonstrates very poor judgement in choice of friends and alternative lifestyle. Amanda ... a college student...who's upbringing in middle class Seatle WA, does not dictate a person capable commiting anything remotely close to this crime. But then I guess one cannot really know a person...Actually, as parents, we hope our children can recognize a bad clique, and run! Unfortunately for her, their lifestyles apealed to her. Now she has 26 yrs to regret her part in the murder.

33214826
Flag this comment

thirdparty said on December 6, 2009 at 7:59 PM

This is third party. My second comment was not posted. Can we leave more then one comment...or did I say something not approved?

33214977
Flag this comment

candydandy said on December 6, 2009 at 8:34 PM

She should have gotten life.

33216002
Flag this comment

sumithryo said on December 6, 2009 at 8:45 PM

sufferingmom - YOU HAVE NO IDEA IF SHE IS INNOCENT, she was found GUILTY in a court of law - yet you want everyone to chip in money for her???? INSANE!!!!!!!!!!!

33216356
Flag this comment

kenpomaster said on December 6, 2009 at 9:21 PM

Shufferingmom, you really need to get yourself checked out at a local institution. Amanda Knox is a murderer. End of the story.

33217452
Flag this comment

jazzysport said on December 6, 2009 at 11:32 PM

A travesty of justice. Mr Knox, sir, you are not in America. Does anyone in this country understand that Italy or any other country is not America. Its amazing to hear people always say for Americans to stay out other countries business. Its alright for dictators and terrorists to committ atrocities on their own people and we are the bad guy for interveneing but when it comes to the justice system in Italy we are supposed to get our politicians involved. Hey, the Italians aren't messing around. The concept of innocent until proven guilty is largely and American concept when you look at just how much it takes to convict someone in America. If every case was to go by the book as it is written in America we would have so many murderers and rapists on the street you would not go out. Americans want more justice for victims and are angry at the crime in this country. What the hell do you expect when it takes all 12 jurors to convict. We are blessed and cursed by our system.

33220829
Flag this comment

mirror_image said on December 7, 2009 at 2:21 AM

I am shocked at these comments you people have forced upon Amanda and her family. Did any of you, so quick to judge, analyze any of the evidence that put her behind bars? The knife that they accused her of using didn't match the wounds found on Meredith Kertchers body, her DNA was not found on the body at all, and the sole witness to the fleeing 'murders' changed her stories more time than anyone else in the entire case. Did any of you research anything before passing judgment? Of course I, or none of you were present at the murder or the trial. As such we cannot assume sure judgment, however we can agree on one common theme- this was not an American trial. As such, the jury is absolutely subject to the media attention given to the trial and influence of others such as the two Judges on the jury. Amanda was painted as guilty since day one by the media. This is the travesty described by her father. I sincerely hope that this corrupt court can realize fault and acquit her. Good luck.

33223596
Flag this comment

w7rkd said on December 7, 2009 at 5:24 AM

I agree with mirror_image and others with alike thinking. Amanda was easy prey for the Italian police and their backwater justice system, they are just as corrupt as the Iranian election that was just held recently. I think theres a slight hint of too much inbreeding gone on in Italy and it has affected their intelect a bit too much! If you think Knox was guilty, maybe you all should move to Italy and try and get away with your narrow minded thinking there, or perhaps China, and when you scream injustice and that your human rights were violated, we over here will just get our the worlds smallest violin and play it for you and throw back your words in your face about how you chastized Amanda without any thought of being factual or fair! If you can dish it out, you can take it too!

33226937
Flag this comment

drcyclops said on December 7, 2009 at 7:45 AM

Unbelievable, shame on all of the readers blasting Knox. And shame on you King5! Any comments that contradict your collective thinking (very unbiased of you, yea right) gets censored and/or cut off period, or you deny comments altogether from ANY of your readers, in some articles. 'nuff said.

33233196
Flag this comment

frenchy said on December 7, 2009 at 8:11 AM

GOSH, this story makes me sick and people complaining about Amanda's fate too !! What is wrong with you ??? IF the same story happened in the states, with a Brit or Italian killing an ALL AMERICAN GIRL, come on, The euro would have gotten LIFE SENTENCE or even death penalty as it exists in some states !! You criticize Italy, Europe, etc. I am French and used to live in Europe and in the Us all my life. NONE of these justices are better !! They ALL have their down sides and paradoxes !! One thing is sure... There is a girl that have been KILLED, throat open... And We talk about is the "poor Seattle girl involved" !!! NONE of these 3 kids, nor Amande, the African or the Italian could make up a real story... They ALL got involved in a way... NOONE was panicked to see the scene and call the cops... They ALL ruined their life and someone's else life. At least her parents can come visit her, not like the Brit's parents, who wil be crying all their lives ! She deserves it as any murderer

33234697
Flag this comment

frankguy said on December 7, 2009 at 9:45 AM

Mr.Knox, did you say travesty of justice? I say 'festivity of justice.'

33239899
Flag this comment

ctcbear said on December 7, 2009 at 12:14 PM

I believe she is guility. Additionally, there are many that go to jail for less evidence in this country. Where is the out rage for theses right at home. She should have told the truth about her role in the murder instead of hiding behind the american citizenship......

33249569
Flag this comment

ld1982 said on December 7, 2009 at 1:48 PM

Frenchy I agree with you 100%. I'm embarassed by what people are saying , and how they're defending Knox. She's a murderer. Period. She got a lighter sentence than what she deserved, and if an American had been killed, the killer would be looking at the death penalty...not 26 years, or even LESS with good behavior. I hope she rots in jail.

33255354
Flag this comment

mirandasmommy said on December 7, 2009 at 1:55 PM

Educate yourselves before you speak. You are just adding to the problem. http://edition.cnn.com/2009/CRIME/12/07/knox.trial.analysis/ Shame on all of you for making judgements before you read the evidence.

33255709
Flag this comment