Print
Email
Share

Expensive studies but no action on Mukilteo Ferry Dock

by LINDA BYRON / KING 5 News

KING5.com

Posted on February 21, 2012 at 10:45 PM

Updated Tuesday, Feb 21 at 11:35 PM

MUKILTEO, Wash. -- When it comes to car travel, the busiest ferry route in the state isn't a Seattle run -- it's the Mukilteo-Clinton run to and from Whidbey Island.

But the tiny Mukilteo terminal was never designed to handle the 2.5 million vehicles it sees every year. And neither was the Mukilteo Speedway -- the only road to and from the ferry dock. Traffic backups create what local residents call the “bar of steel” that cuts the community in two. All along the Mukilteo Speedway there are funky workarounds to facilitate traffic flow.

There are signs directing motorists who want to make a turn into town to cross directly in front of ferry traffic lined up along the speedway. It’s a recipe for confusion and collisions.
 
“It’s gotten kind of overworked. Time for a change,” said Mukilteo resident Dennis Gillingham.
 
Mukilteo Mayor Joe Marine agrees. The change Marine wants is to move the ferry terminal to the northeast end of an abandoned tank farm where the Air Force once stored jet fuel.
 
"For years our community stared at these twenty-foot tanks that just sat out here,” Marine said. “I mean this is our opportunity to fix the problem that we have with ferry traffic and at the same time, get that public access to the beach that we desire," he said.
 
That plan, called “Elliot Point 1” is just one of four options the Washington State Department of Transportation is considering. It’s also the most expensive with a price tag of about $160 million. That’s nearly three times what it would cost to replacing the existing dock without making improvements.
 
Mukilteo City Council members Kevin Stoltz and Steve Schmalz oppose the $160 million plan.

"The state doesn't have that,” Stoltz said, “and I don't know why we keep thinking that as long as it's somebody else's money, it's miraculously going to appear.”
 
It's true the state ferry system is broke -- with a $1.3 billion budget deficit projected over the next decade. But critics say lawmakers and WSDOT have no one to blame but themselves for the Mukilteo mess.
 
Mayor Marine has a study that was commissioned in 1969 to evaluate what should be done to improve traffic flow and handle increased traffic volumes on the ferry run.
 
Published in 1972, the 40-year-old study recommended WSDOT move the ferry dock to the end of the tank farm.
 
"It's a metaphor for, 'Let's talk about it some more, let's study it some more, but really never solve the issue,'” Marine said.
 
Instead of acting on that 1972 study, WSDOT commissioned two more studies.
 
What did all that cost? To date, $24.4 million in studies, with no work done on a new dock.
 
“I happen to think that it's financially irresponsible to spend $25 million and really have nothing to show for it," Councilman Steve Schmalz said.
 
Emergency band aids have kept the dock operating. But the ferry officials concede it will have to be torn down soon, with or without a decision on its replacement.

WSDOT is holding two hearings this week, one in Mukilteo on Wednesday and one in Clinton on Thursday, to get input on the four options under consideration for the so called “Mukilteo Multimodal Project.”

For more info on the public hearings, click here.
 

Print
Email
Share
 

To add a comment, please register or login.

1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Comments: Displaying 1 - 12 of 12

Jake-518 said on February 23, 2012 at 11:09 PM

@freedomfrank You're partly right about pulling the PT ferries without a plan. The other part was they decided to pull them at the very end of their lives, leaving PT with no ferries at all for a while, which in turn hurt a lot of business in PT. When Port Townsend did get a temporary replacement ferry, they got a toy boat.

82098792
Flag this comment

eagle86 said on February 22, 2012 at 8:31 AM

Everyone lets go out tonight to the "Bar of Steel" Get out on the dance floor and do the "funky workaround!!"

81907874
Flag this comment

tootoo said on February 22, 2012 at 8:03 AM

@comiccon2010 Because privatizing public services will bring in honest companies and honest workers that will give lower fares because they are more efficient...right? Get real, privatizing NEVER costs citizens less. It just makes a select few people richer. But Republicans love making a select few people richer on the dime of citizens, hence why they love privatization.

81904512
Flag this comment

quackula said on February 22, 2012 at 7:48 AM

I recommend we spend money on another study to find out why the studies were so expensive in the first place.

81902704
Flag this comment

freedomfrank said on February 22, 2012 at 7:34 AM

Kinda hard not to blame em Stone,, they have been running the state for how long now? I agree with you though, its the government as a whole and our fault for not getting the right people in to represent US

81900912
Flag this comment

stonetrails said on February 22, 2012 at 6:37 AM

stonetrails avatar

I don't want to sound discourteous or impolite. . . But, if you (you know who you are) really think this is s democrat or republican issue you need to open your eyes and take a closer look at what is really going on. The fact is, they are ALL stealing your money. "It's the democrats", "it's the republicans". . . Really? Seriously? They obviously have you right where they want you. Stop pointing your finger at one side or the other. It is the government, as a whole, that is destroying all of our American dreams.

81894484
Flag this comment

jcman said on February 22, 2012 at 6:23 AM

This is even worse than all the studies for the 520 bridge. 40 years and nothing to show for the money. IMO, anytime the state contracts for a study, it's a waste of tax money. They could use their own employees to do studies and get just as good results and the workers would actually be doing something.

81893274
Flag this comment

Mingledchime said on February 22, 2012 at 6:23 AM

@freedomfrank - - "This state is run by a bunch of buffoons. Your democrats hard at work folks,,,," - - Who voted them in? Aren't they to take some of the blame as well? We are all being screwed by the bad decisions made by not just those we elect to office, but by just about everyone - regardless of their political affiliation - who is in a position of power and influence. Most people who aspire to positions of power are those who have a need to wield power but generally have very little good common sense and are so far removed from the consequences of any problems they create that they never feel the pinch or bite of pain the rest of us do. Many of these decision makers are wealthy and in a class that is out of touch with the reality of the rest of us. Most admin types do nothing but attend meetings and make bad decisions all day long that adversely affect the rest of us and there is no real accountability, or more importantly, any way to counter their bad decisions.

81893262
Flag this comment

freedomfrank said on February 22, 2012 at 6:08 AM

But the ferry officials concede it will have to be torn down soon, with or without a decision on its replacement. Kinda like when the pulled the Pt Townsend boats without a plan. This state is run by a bunch of buffoons. Your democrats hard at work folks,,,,

81891742
Flag this comment

comiccon2010 said on February 22, 2012 at 12:26 AM

privatize it, the ferry workers are thieves anyways. as usual the democrats in ofice just keep writing blank checks for inadequate services. just look at dshs and the millions they flush weekly

81880842
Flag this comment

Anonymous said on February 22, 2012 at 12:24 AM

Sooner or later the military is going to have to clean up the abandoned tank farm. Why wasn't that reported in this article? I would be willing to bet that the inevitable cleanup is probably a minimum of 3/4 of the cost of this entire project. Do some more research and get back to us with the whole story.

81880774
Flag this comment

HomeHorthwest said on February 21, 2012 at 11:32 PM

$25 Million for ferry cronies! $25 millions for ferry cronies! ...and they could not find the funds to get workers to fix a traffic sign to get worker to work on time.... $25 million for ferry cronies! $25 million for cronies! Question is who are these ferry cronies? $2 Million per week taken out of college budgets to support Occupy. $5 million for bicycle. $25 Million for ferry cronies. ...but no money for tax payers trying to get to work through broken traffic lights... Hum?

81878762
Flag this comment