Share this article:
Print

Amanda Knox found guilty in Italy murder trial

Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

by KING 5 News / KING5.com Staff

Posted on December 4, 2009 at 4:58 PM

Updated Saturday, Dec 5 at 1:36 PM

******

PERUGIA, Italy - While the trial took almost a year, a jury found former University of Washington student Amanda Knox and her Italian former boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito guilty of the stabbing murder of British exchange student Meredith Kercher.

Knox was sentenced to 26 years in prison, Sollecito was sentenced to 25 years.

The eight members of the jury, including two judges, reached their decision after deliberating for about nine hours in the courtroom Friday. In Italy, a unanimous verdict is not required, only a majority.

Knox sobbed as guards led her out of the courtroom. Sollecito's stepmother reportedly screamed at the court when the verdicts were read. Knox's parents appeared stunned and devastated by the verdict and left the courtoom crying and holding hands.

"It's absolutely unbelievable," said Cassandra Knox, Amanda's stepmother. "We will fight on. That's all we can do."

Hours after the verdict was read, Knox's father, Curt, called it a travesty and said the jury didn't have the courage to do the right thing. He said they let down their own community and the justice system. He is vowing to fight on to free her through appeal.

Curt says the family hopes to visit Amanda in prison on Saturday but, if not, he will see her on their regular visit.

Knox, who has spent the last two years in an Italian jail cell, was also convicted of a series of additional charges including sexual assault, conspiracy, faking a burglary and slandering a man she falsely implicated in the crime. Knox and Sollecito were convicted on all charges except theft and together must pay 5 million euros, approximately $7,427,000 U.S., to Kercher's family. 

Prosecutors sought a life sentence for both, including nine months of daytime solitary confinement for Knox and two months for Sollecito. Knox's defense lawyers say the fact that she was not sentenced for life is a good indication for an appeal. Attorneys say both will appeal.

The Knox/Mellas family released a statement following the verdict.

"
We are extremely disappointed in the verdict rendered today against our daughter," read part of the statement. "While we always knew this was a possibility, we find it difficult to accept this verdict when we know that she is innocent, and that the prosecution has failed to explain why there is no evidence of Amanda in the room where Meredith was so horribly and tragically murdered."

Meredith Kercher's family said Saturday they were pleased with the murder conviction but said there was no sense of celebration.

"Ultimately we are pleased with the decision, pleased that we've got a decision, but it's not a time for celebration," Lyle Kercher, the victim's brother, said.

Kercher's sister, Stephanie, said the verdict "does bring a a little bit of justice, for us and for her."

"Life will never be the same without Mez," she said.

Knox and Sollecito, were charged with murder and sexual violence in the November 2007 knifing death of Meredith Kercher. Knox and Kercher, a British exchange student, were roommates in Perugia, a university town about 115 miles (185 kilometers) north of Rome. Knox and Sollecito were arrested shortly after the slaying.

A third suspect, Rudy Guede, was found guilty in a separate trial and is appealing.

Prosecutors say Kercher died during a twisted sex game in which Knox taunted Kercher while Sollecito and Guede sexually assaulted her.

The prosecution says a knife, found in Sollecito's house, was the murder weapon and had Knox's DNA on the handle and Kercher's on the blade, among other pieces of evidence.

The defense has claimed the knife doesn't match Kercher's wounds or an imprint of a knife left on a bedsheet. They also claimed the DNA sample is too small to be conclusive.

The defense has argued that Guede, who was convicted in a separate fast-track trial, was the sole killer. The defense has said there is no evidence tying the three suspects together or proving they planned Kercher's murder.

Knox has given contradicting versions, saying at one point that she was home the night of the murder and had heard Kercher's screams and accusing a Congolese man of the killing. The man, Patrick Diya Lumumba, owns a pub in Perugia where Knox worked. He was jailed briefly but was later cleared and is seeking defamation damages from Knox.

Knox said police pressure led her to initially accuse an innocent man.

Prosecutors say Knox and Sollecito broke a window in a bedroom to stage a burglary and sidetrack the investigation.

During Thursday's final arguments, Knox took the stand for a second time, telling jurors in her Italian murder trial she is not an "assassin" who killed her former roommate. Knox previously testified in June.

Standing up, her voice breaking as she fought back tears, the 22-year-old Seattle student told the court that she feels "vulnerable" and fears losing herself after two years in jail.

"I have written on a piece of paper ... that I was afraid of losing myself," she said, speaking Italian. "I am scared of being branded what I am not," she said. "I am scared of having the mask of an assassin forced onto me."

Sollecito, also addressing the court Thursday, insisted that no motive had emerged to explain his alleged role in the slaying. He disputed the prosecution's view that he was submissive toward Amanda and had been manipulated by her.

"Not having found a motive to explain why I would kill, they said I was a sort of dog on a leash," he said. "If Amanda had asked me to do something I didn't agree with, I would have said no. Let alone if she had asked me to do something as terrible as killing a girl."

Knox and Sollecito have been jailed for more than two years. Their trial began in January.

Italian law allows for suspects in serious crimes to be jailed even before indictment, if they are considered a flight risk among other reasons. Knox is likely to remain in jail, even though in Italy sentences are not served until all appeals are exhausted, a process that can take years.

Within 90 days, the jury will submit a report listing their reasons for their decision.

KING 5's Linda Byron and the Associated Press contributed to this report.

 

 

Share this article:
Print

To add a comment, please register or login.

Leave your comment
1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

HTML is not allowed.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

homeslicebryce said on December 4, 2009 at 4:26 PM

That sucks :( Remind me never to go to Italy!

33119911
Flag this comment

marliss said on December 4, 2009 at 4:43 PM

King5 only supports comments which support a convicted murderess.

33120499
Flag this comment

lovewashington said on December 4, 2009 at 4:43 PM

Like she wasn't guilty??? I do feel sorry for her family but she was conviced in a court of law. Now Meredith Kercher's family can have closure. God be with Meredith and Amands's family.

33120509
Flag this comment

roxwarren said on December 4, 2009 at 4:54 PM

You will never convince me that Amanda Knox is guilty. Exhaustion and sleep deprivation of prison life, which are effective in yielding confessions, never once caused her to say she did it! A cop killer can fall through the cracks for years, and a student traveling abroad wrong place wrong time treated far far worse. I will not be traveling to Italy

33120934
Flag this comment

hippiegirl said on December 4, 2009 at 4:59 PM

Although I do feel bad that a young woman will be sent to prison for 26 years, I never had a doubt in my mind that she was anything but guilty. But I don't feel too bad for her, after all she's not the victim here. Meredith Kircher was the victim. It's a shame that Amanda didn't make better choices in who to hang out with, say no to smoking marijuana, and get caught up in murder and its coverup. She should have been having the time of her life studying in Italy. She's where she is because of poor choices, plus I believe she's a little bit psychotic.

33121109
Flag this comment

jerbear1 said on December 4, 2009 at 5:19 PM

I feel for Amanda Knox, I feel that it was the wrong verdict. Very wrong thing that happen to such a smart and pretty young lady. I also feel for her family. Italy justice system sucks. J.B. Seattle

33121911
Flag this comment

sal723 said on December 4, 2009 at 5:24 PM

Amanda Knox may be guilty, and until recently studying this case and the Italian system of Justice, I was convinced she is. However, it seems that many of the alleged forensic items proving her guilt, I.e. the DNA, have in fact been greatly compromised by the Carabinieri and other law enforcement and Criminal Investigation agencies. Further, to those who have stated that the Italian system of Justice worked well, in Italy all that is needed for a verdict of guilty is a simple majority, 5 to 4 and guilt is allowed in a capital murder case, unlike the US which requires a unanimous verdict. It does not work well, and those who are expressing glee might do well to pray that they never end up on the wrong side of the law outside of American borders. Those who are certain that they never will are naive. Justice may have been served, but the decisions will always be clouded and shaded in gray as a result of an inequitable system of justice. Perugia, Italy is a wonderful city.

33122097
Flag this comment

w7rkd said on December 4, 2009 at 5:37 PM

This is a severe injustice! I have never been labeled a radical, but you might as well call me one now! I call on all computer hackers to spam, jam, infect, and crash the Italian governments computer infrastructure continuously untill the "WAPS" reverse the decision and clear Amanda of the charges! The Judge was a crook from the start, the jury was tainted from the start having 2 judges seated in the jury, which means alot of coersion and outside influence for a decision against Amanda, they were only looking out for the judge conducting the trial to save his immage and create bravado for him and his next book! I for oneam not going to buy another made in Italy product either, they all can go pound sand!

33122567
Flag this comment

crowlover said on December 4, 2009 at 5:44 PM

Has there been one expert or forensic phycho. who has profiled AK as a killer-NO of course not. Anyone with half a brain & an ounce of common sense knows she did not rape & murder Meredith. Hippiegirl is an idiot who obviously never went to college, was never a kid and never once used poor judgment. Like smoking marijuana has ANYTHING to do with sexual assault & murder. Lovewashington is equally as clueless. My children know more about justice than you two. What happened to MOTIVE? No plausible motive has ever been defined for why AK would murder her friend. Further, what about EVIDENCE. Do us a favor and move to Italy. Amanda Knox is innocent.

33122956
Flag this comment

sherilynn said on December 4, 2009 at 6:09 PM

I watched the court room "antics" in the Amanda Knox trial and it made me sick. "False Drama" by the prosecuting attorney, using a female voice and acting out like "He was there"? Excuse me, that is not a "Fact", that is a "Fabrication", "Fiction". We base everything in courts on "Facts". Facts are Truths. Innocent until proven quilty? What happened to that? Amanda Knox and her family should be proud of her. I'm proud of her. America should be proud of her! What bravery she has shown in that room with Italy's most "Corrupt" prosecutor, and "Excuse me" the JUDGE? 26 years for an innocent person? Are they NUTS? I had dreams of one day going to Italy, Not any more! They can keep their olives, cheese, leather goods and what ever else they toss out to the world to make a buck. I'll just enjoy the picture books in the 2nd hand book stores, it's a lot cheaper, and safer.

33124069
Flag this comment

proudamerican said on December 4, 2009 at 6:10 PM

Linda Byron is clearly not unbiased. Shame on her and K5 for the 5:00 storyline regarding the appeal.

33124114
Flag this comment

vicktrola said on December 4, 2009 at 6:28 PM

Thank God that jurors in Italy have more common sense and intelligence than those here in the USA (especially Los Angeles). Knox and Sollecito are just as "innocent" as OJ. Those who think otherwise have obviously not studied the evidence objectively and thoroughly enough. This news makes my day. I only wish they had gotten 30 years, same as Guede.

33124846
Flag this comment

vicktrola said on December 4, 2009 at 6:29 PM

Thank God that jurors in Italy have more common sense and intelligence than those here in the USA (especially Los Angeles). Knox and Sollecito are just as "innocent" as OJ. Those who think otherwise have obviously not studied the evidence objectively and thoroughly enough. This news makes my day. I only wish they had gotten 30 years, same as Guede.

33124859
Flag this comment

adventure_some said on December 4, 2009 at 6:34 PM

People are so stupid. Of course she was guilty. She kept changing her story. Just like a lawyer you keep shooting arrows until one sticks. In this case, they kept trying to refute the FACTS. Oh Italy, doesn't know how to conduct a trial or understand the law. Now that our reputable senator Cantwell is going to come to the rescue lol, lol, lol. Heck she get out of jail and be millionaire in 20 years. Who makes that kind of money? So in the end she makes out pretty good. GUILTY!

33125042
Flag this comment

djnorwegian said on December 4, 2009 at 6:36 PM

Having two young adult daughters living in Seattle, I was deeply pained when I learned of the guilty verdict, an abject travesty in my view. I've closely followed this case and have been outraged at the conduct of Italian police and prosecutors and lack of any indisputable evidence. Ms. Knox was physically and psychologically abused by her captors, forcing an imprudent early confession, out of her need to make the onslaught stop. Since then the bizarre, scandalous lead prosecutor made an ugly mockery of what we here would consider fair justice. No prior or subsequent behavior of Ms. Knox's remotely suggests she has the motive or capacity for such a heinous act, whereas the man already in prison for the crime does. Sloppy forensic work and the sensationalizing of this trial for personal aggrandizement led to Ms. Knox's horrible predicament and now fate. I side with other commenters in that I will never set foot in Italy. What a primitive and rigged legal system and despicable press.

33125094
Flag this comment

shawnc36 said on December 4, 2009 at 6:37 PM

I have done a lot of research on this case of Amanda Knox for Kaplan University Criminal Justice classes. Even some of the professors where dumbfounded over the investigative process used in gathering the evidence. In our discussions in class over this whole case, it boiled down to a couple things. In 2006 Italy charged 23 CIA personnel of kidnapping/abducting Italian civilians and convicted the 23 in an absentee trail. In 2007 Amanda Knox was charged with murder. We came to the conclusion that it was more political then actually justice to prevail. Italian's feeling violated by the CIA and not getting any justice for what they did in 2006 so when Amanda Knox case showed up it gave the Italian government an opportunity to get some type of justice against an American.

33125109
Flag this comment

proudamerican said on December 4, 2009 at 6:44 PM

Maria Cantwell's press release is just political posturing. She makes comments as if she was there listening to the evidence herself. She said, "The prosecution did not present enough evidence for an impartial jury to conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that Ms. Knox was guilty." How on earth does she know this to be fact? Shame on you as well Senator Cantwell.

33125351
Flag this comment

karinanne said on December 4, 2009 at 6:45 PM

I'm not so sure she is guitly. But was pretty sure the Italian Jury would find her guilty. Their justice sytem is not the same as ours. Not by a long shot! Being questioned for 14 hours without benefit of an attorney. Wow . We Americans tend to forget just how different things are in foreign countries. My vacations are limited to the mainland or Hawaii. I feel sorry for her, if she's truely innocent.

33125379
Flag this comment

gamooch1974 said on December 4, 2009 at 6:46 PM

oH poor Amanda, I think alot is being missed here. Oh like the poor young beautiful girl who was murdered. Yeah i think Amanda had something to do with it. She was there and she knew what was going on. 26 years is nothing compaired to what that murdered girl and the girls parents get to live with...

33125399
Flag this comment

proudamerican said on December 4, 2009 at 6:50 PM

All you Italy bashers, get a grip. Italy is a wonderful place to live. I was there for 2 years and had a GREAT time. Just don't break the law. Doing drugs and committing MURDER will get you in trouble. Duh! Just like it will anywhere else.

33125587
Flag this comment

fedupinwa said on December 4, 2009 at 6:52 PM

Best news other that Maurice Clemmons being shot to death.

33125634
Flag this comment

cementmixer said on December 4, 2009 at 6:52 PM

This news just leaves me even more depressed after all that's happened this week. She is innocent. Bring her home as soon as possible. Let's hope the appeal is as speedy as possible and finds her Not Guilty. She didn't do the crime. No way.

33125661
Flag this comment

fedupinwa said on December 4, 2009 at 6:53 PM

Everybody in prision is innocent.

33125692
Flag this comment

gamooch1974 said on December 4, 2009 at 6:55 PM

thank you proudamerican. It's not Italy fault Amanada is a Murderer.Maybe they need to look into the drugs she did that night, drinking and people she let influence her to murder.People always trying to put blame on other thingsor people then actually paying consecences for your action.Welcome to the real world Amanda.

33125779
Flag this comment

udub81 said on December 4, 2009 at 7:01 PM

Yes, it is sad for Amanda, her family, and supporters. Oh wait, she's NOT the victim, she wasn't the one murdered, it was Meredith. Remember her? Amanda will have the opportunity to appeal, to change the her circumstances, but Meredith and family never will. It's shameful the way the local media, Amanda's family and supporters are carrying on, they should be doing their protests behind the scenes, vehemently, strongly, but with dignity. The way they're behaving publicly could backfire/damage Amanda's appeal chances.

33125976
Flag this comment

cmarie said on December 4, 2009 at 7:05 PM

I don't know why I care but I have been following this matter for two years. Can't decide if she is or isn't guilty-nonetheless my heart goes out to whoever is involved if they are innocent

33126079
Flag this comment

shawnc36 said on December 4, 2009 at 7:15 PM

Some people really have no idea of what transpired or what happened during the collection of evidence, nor do most understand international court systems. Your guilty until proven innocent. Also the jury is made up of 2 judges and 4 citizens that can read the anti-american slandering newspapers or news on the television. So how can you have an impartial trial when them two parts are involved. Not to mention most just want to spout off without knowing anything except what they saw on the television today.

33126357
Flag this comment

crazeebiker said on December 4, 2009 at 7:16 PM

Is she guilty of murder, only a few people really know the truth. I am convinced she is not telling everything she knows about the events of that night. Perhaps she's scared, protecting someone else or herself. Amanda the truth will set you free! Please lets all keep the victim and her family in your thoughts and prayers. Remember Amanda's family can still visit her but Meredith's family no longer has that right, it was taken from them through no fault of theirs.

33126412
Flag this comment

alcamomix said on December 4, 2009 at 7:33 PM

IM ITALIAN AND KILLING O BE PART OF I CRIME IS ILEGAL EVERY WHERE, THE LAST TIME I CHECK,THIS HAPPENT EVERY DAY HERE IS USA TO FORIGNERS GOING TO JAIL FOR LIFE SOME TIMES THEY ARE INOCENT BUT NO BOTY CARE BUT WHENE HAPPENT TO ONE AMERICAN IS ALL OVER THE NEWS..REALY SAD...

33126954
Flag this comment

tnashley1 said on December 4, 2009 at 7:35 PM

Don't do the crime if you can't do the time! and most definitely not in another country! ! !

33127014
Flag this comment

jim_scott said on December 4, 2009 at 7:51 PM

This is an injustice of the highest order. My heart goes out to Amanda, her family and friends. I don’t believe the evidence presented was sufficient to conclude guilt. I hope her appeal is timely and successful. This is a tragedy for all concerned and one that needs to be corrected.

33127514
Flag this comment

nemesis133 said on December 4, 2009 at 8:11 PM

This is just ridiculous. The Italian prosecutor, Giuliano Mignini, is completely insane and has a record of being an idiot about things like Amanda's case before, as evidenced in the book "The Monster of Florence: A True Story". In the book (this is true!) Mignini went after famed writer Douglas Preston and italian journalist Mario Spezi because of their interest in catching a serial killer in Tuscany, saying that satanic worship was somehow involved. I do not believe for a second that Amanda is guilty or that the evidence was enough to conclude her guilt. The argument against Amanda is simply weak. And I hear that they already have a man in jail for the EXACT SAME crime. Amanda had nothing to do with this, let's hope she gets out soon.

33128212
Flag this comment

justjack said on December 4, 2009 at 8:12 PM

Dear Amanda, Why are you so shocked that they found you guilty ?? You did it and you know you did !! Why are guilty people so shocked to be found guilty ? You really believe that just because you are a young American visiting a foreign country that you can pull your BS and get away with it. You even sold your family out. They are now broke, both financially and in spirit. May you rot in your new 26 year home.

33128299
Flag this comment

seattleboi said on December 4, 2009 at 8:37 PM

Everyone seems to just know Foxy Knoxy is either innocent or guilty - but based on what facts? How does everyone just happen to know one way or another as we sit here halfway around the globe? True, the prosecution couldn't really prove she directly murdered Kercher or that she was even there; but Knox also couldn't prove she could not have commited the crime or that she wasn't there. And, if memory serves me correctly, didn't she also incriminate someone early on? Only Knox knows if she's guilty or not. Incidently, her sentence is more like 28 years since the last two don't count towards it. If she behaves herself she may get out earlier, and upon returning to the US will become wealthy through book deals, talk shows, lectures, and of course Hollyhood. A sentence can be commuted - it's happened before.

33129146
Flag this comment

vocaltremors said on December 4, 2009 at 8:38 PM

I say we send in some of our elite Special Forces and remove Ms. Knox from Italy. Italians can't even clean up the mob from their society, so it absolutely ridiculous to think that they could honestly give anyone a fair trial. Hell, Italy is only a hop, skip, and a jump from being a third world country, so they really are irrelevant.

33129224
Flag this comment

hdwindy said on December 4, 2009 at 8:45 PM

As the world turns

33129461
Flag this comment

lovewashington said on December 4, 2009 at 8:58 PM

Oops my bad. It was Sen. Maria Cantwell, not Patty Murry. Sorry about that Sen. Murry.

33129962
Flag this comment

ptown said on December 4, 2009 at 9:26 PM

She should not have been doing drugs in another country. She should not have confessed to being there (at the scene of the crime) and then recanted her story. She should not have been doing cartwheels. She should not have been shopping for sex toys. If she didn't commit the murder, she should not be acting like a fool for the whole world to see. This media circus is created by her own behavior. It's not really looking good for her family either. They should NOT be bad mouthing Italy to the media. They should just shut their mouths. I do not know if she killed Merideth or not but her behavior does look bad to me and to the eyes of the Italian court.

33130776
Flag this comment

spidey said on December 4, 2009 at 9:30 PM

A lot of people here need to get out and travel, there is a world, a very interesting world beyond the US. I'm actually very disappointed by the coverage as it all assumes she's innocent. Whatever happened to objective journalism?? Would it have made a difference if she was not from the NW, not attending the UW, not from a "well-to-do-family"? If she is a killer, she is a killer - lets not forget that just because she is from the NW, was attending the UW and is from a "well-to-do-family". My heart goes to both families who's lives are changed forever.

33130944
Flag this comment

pugetsoundfan said on December 4, 2009 at 9:30 PM

I don't believe that Amanda is guilty, but like everyone else that remarks on this site, I don't have enough information to back my beliefs up. It simply amazes me how many people are absolutely sure of her guilt or innocence based upon the reports from the media. It sounds like the Italian lawyers had a hard time sorting fact out in the courtroom, yet we choose to bicker based on opinion. This case is a tragedy from the beginning...from the horrific, senseless death of a young girl, to the possibility of two young people being detained unfairly. I have doubts that the courts feel that they had a clear view of the truth or they would not have lowered the sentence to 25 years. Two more years to wait during an appeal process is a long time...but hopefully, the defense and prosecution will find the truth in all of this. Until then, the families of all of these young adults (the dead and accused) need our support and compassion. Nothing is more inappropriate than misplaced vengeance

33130949
Flag this comment

withane said on December 4, 2009 at 9:43 PM

Am I missing something here? When I was in college I don't remember any of us playing sex games with knives with our roommates.

33131409
Flag this comment

fedupinwa said on December 4, 2009 at 10:05 PM

I wonder if her parents get a refund for the airline ticket they bought her. Good riddence Amanda, may to rot in your cell & cry how innocent you are.What about your roomate, she cannot tell her side. May the knox family finally go away.She's old news.

33132034
Flag this comment

yoda_ said on December 4, 2009 at 10:06 PM

where's my comment?

33132084
Flag this comment

alcamomix said on December 4, 2009 at 10:09 PM

and my comment???

33132131
Flag this comment

vocaltremors said on December 4, 2009 at 10:33 PM

See, the treehugger patrol removes posts.... that's where your comment went. Some tree hugger didn't like what you said and had it removed.

33132809
Flag this comment

vocaltremors said on December 4, 2009 at 10:35 PM

Quit removing my posts treehugger

33132891
Flag this comment

yiseunggi said on December 4, 2009 at 10:44 PM

To tell you the truth, I think the Italians didnt give her a chance to speak for herself. Poor girl.

33133157
Flag this comment

vocaltremors said on December 4, 2009 at 10:56 PM

HUH?

33133499
Flag this comment

nky86 said on December 4, 2009 at 11:05 PM

Amanda Knox got what she deserved! I hope she fries in jail. Those who kill deserve to get punished! This brings closure to Meredith's family! Of course Amanda's family is going to defend her even though she's guilty. In the end, the jury and the judge are the ones who make the final decision and I definitely agree with this decision! Muah!

33133914
Flag this comment

djnorwegian said on December 4, 2009 at 11:45 PM

What an embarrassing state of minds that spawned many of the spite-filled comments above, rife with illogic, misinformation, ignorance, and unbridled prejudice. If you were to actually study the case, you'd find that not a single shred of DNA or other evidence in the bedroom where the prosecution fantasized that Ms. Knox committed the vicious murder was found of either Ms. Knox's or the Italian boy's. The tiny trace of so-called DNA of the English girl's on the kitchen knife found in the boy's apartment couldn't even be positively ID'd as human, let alone belonging to the victim. Any other alleged evidence of Ms. Knox's in the female students' bathroom is completely consistent with her living there. I'm dismayed at many of the negative comments because they're reflective of the loss of critical thinking, so abysmally evident in this country -- and elsewhere, for that matter. Oh, and don't forget the jury wasn't even screened for predispositions induced by the crazed Italian media.

33135292
Flag this comment

honestahol said on December 4, 2009 at 11:55 PM

Well, what goes around comes around...

33135567
Flag this comment

vicktrola said on December 4, 2009 at 11:55 PM

Gee, was Linda Byron actually crying after the verdict? Sure sounds and looks like it. Did this story even ONCE mention the reaction of the Kercher family to the verdict? So much for objective journalism! Must be that the Kerchers' composure and class throughout this whole thing doesn't make for as good of press as the obnoxious behavior of the defendants' families. (It's apparent here that the apples didn't fall far from their trees). Linda Byron should have been glad to see that obnoxious smile finally wiped off Knoxy's face . . .

33135571
Flag this comment

janice60 said on December 5, 2009 at 12:00 AM

This whole thing is so very sad. However, I feel Amanda Knox is not guilty. To many things points to it. For one thing evidence. The knife was not the same knife. The other thing that really bothered me is when the juriors came back in a lot of them were wearing the Italian colors of their Country Flag. That told me right then, they were making a political statement. This trial was a travesty and mostly a lynching. I shall never travel to Italy and that was one of the places I had always planned and dreamed to visit.

33135729
Flag this comment

davidadams said on December 5, 2009 at 12:00 AM

Tsk Tsk.. all of it SOOOO easily preventable.... don't stab someone to death and you stay out of prison.. oh well..lessons learned

33135731
Flag this comment

blankingout said on December 5, 2009 at 12:04 AM

I am sorry, two years ago I felt bad about Kercher... but now I am actually getting kinda of tired hearing about her or seeing that awful ugly picture of her in the devil costume...

33135774
Flag this comment

jenintn said on December 5, 2009 at 1:07 AM

Having worked in an American court system for the past 17 years, I have learned not to make assumptions before hearing both sides of a case. I have also learned over the years that you shouldn't believe everything you hear in the media. Like fellow commenter, justjack, I also have read "The Monster of Florence," written by American author, Douglas Preston, and Italian journalist, Mario Spezi. The prosecutor, Giuliano Mignini, was corrupt in the Monster case and has been just as corrupt in this case. Paul Ciolino, a top criminal defense investigator, was hired by CBS's "48 Hours" to travel to Perugia to review the evidence. He went thinking that she was probably guilty. After ten days of reviewing all the evidence, he said that the prosecution of Amanda Knox was a "railroad job from hell" and a "police-generated fairy tale." I believe that she and Raffaele are innocent and I truly hope that they are successful with their appeal.

33137659
Flag this comment

w7rkd said on December 5, 2009 at 1:29 AM

The Italians sided with Hitler, we had a don in prison here and we made him a deal to get out and turn the mafia against Hitler, then the Italians turn right back around and go communist, and we all know how that works out, your for the party or your dead. So now we have a young woman being painted the fall guy for sensationale for this judge who has been known to pull stunts like this, he places 2 other judge buddies on the jury to make sure he gets what he wants, a guilty verdict! We should of let bubba have the don in prison, and let hitlers SS do genocide on the counrty of Italy before we AMERICANS liberated them. Like I said, the judge is going to make millions on the book he's going to write, to fill his self centered ego, at the expense of other honest people. Boycot Italy! There are other countries that are more deserving than that place!

33138094
Flag this comment

mirader said on December 5, 2009 at 3:36 AM

Amanda did NOT get a fair trial. They convicted her on nothing but that is how most prosecuters get their promotions is on conviction rates. This even happens here in the USA. Prosecuter can have fact of innocence and will stil try to convict. I am sure most of us did not know Amanda and do not know if she comitted the crimes. The evidence in court pretty much nothing and/or fabricated. This is a serious blow to any justice system in the world. If she did comit this crime, she does deserve punishment. But they had actually no proof and convicted her. You could see through all the coverage that the prosecuter probably has no education. In Italy they convict mob bosses for multiple cold blooded murders and they only receive maybe 5 years at the most if not probation. I feel it should be retried immediatley in another country other than Italy or america. like I said, none of us know Amanda or the facts. But the Italian court was totally out of line with what they convicted her with.

33141749
Flag this comment

chubbs said on December 5, 2009 at 8:15 AM

Boycott Italy and everything italian.

33148614
Flag this comment

2lanepavement said on December 5, 2009 at 9:58 AM

All matters of guilt and innocense aside, one does not want to become ensnared in another nation's legal system. Makes me thankful for our system, as flawed as it might be at times.

33152816
Flag this comment

madeintx said on December 5, 2009 at 10:38 AM

I'm so glad this is over! And just like her family kept insisting all along. In the end the truth will be known. Guilty!

33154376
Flag this comment

sp2009 said on December 5, 2009 at 11:11 AM

OJ DID IT!!!

33155654
Flag this comment

bellinghamguy said on December 5, 2009 at 2:00 PM

It must be difficult for both families. First, a life was lost and we need to focus on that first. Second, Amanda was involved and her story changed multiple times. The DNA evidence plus cross examination accounts show she was the one holding the blade that killed the innocent girl during a sex induced drug act. Shame on her for blaming the innocent bar owner she worked for during the initial investigation. She has no shame and should have told her family to drop everything before they are both emotional and financial bankrupt. She is guilty and needs to serve her time.

33161464
Flag this comment

bellinghamguy said on December 5, 2009 at 2:06 PM

Also, do yourself and the life that was lost justice by reading and reviewing additional news sources. Look at CBC, BBC, ITN, RNT and other news agencies to gain more information. I find it to be a sad situation when our local media does not even discuss who the victim was but makes the charged killer the victim. I can understand a families denial but she was into drug, kinky sex and changed her story multiple times. In addition, she put the blame on her boss the pub owner with a made up story who happens to be one of the only minorities in town. I think that is another crime on top of murder.

33161701
Flag this comment

jb55pisces said on December 5, 2009 at 3:19 PM

I think A LOT of anti-Americanism played a BIG part of the Italian jury's ability to reach a verdict so quickly, and I find that completely despicable. The Italian prosecuter's evidence was weak, some evidence that would've shown Amanda Knox to be innocent was disallowed, and she was subjected to grueling police interrogation and torture. This kinda reminds me of "Midnight Express". I'll NEVER EVER go to Italy! J.E.B. Kennewick, WA

33164084
Flag this comment

chiporiley said on December 5, 2009 at 4:44 PM

I believe the all Italian jury may have just convicted George W. Bush in the Amanda Knox trial.

33166739
Flag this comment

vocaltremors said on December 5, 2009 at 4:48 PM

Again, these Italian idiots who can't even get the mob out of their country, would be still goosestepping to Hitler's grandchildren if it weren't for us. I think they should just give her back to us, where at least our criminal justice system would be fair and honest. Let's face facts, that whole nation's freedom is based on good old American bloodshed. I think they owe us... As for the Kercher family... they should shut up as well, as the Brits owe us too. They're just lucky Hitler never bombed them into extinction, period.

33166906
Flag this comment

blankingout said on December 5, 2009 at 4:52 PM

hmm. interesting he was president after all when they arrested her and the trial started...

33167009
Flag this comment

chiporiley said on December 5, 2009 at 5:57 PM

George W. Bush’s policies, posture and demeanor not only fostered contempt and retribution toward the US citizenry by the Italian populous, but also to the majority of populations worldwide

33169144
Flag this comment

factoid said on December 5, 2009 at 6:35 PM

Blame President Bush? Really? I mean this is just absurd. A new intellectual corrupt low even for liberals.

33170179
Flag this comment

ohmygoodness said on December 5, 2009 at 7:17 PM

No mention has ever been made that, perhaps, drugs OTHER THAN marijuana were involved, perhaps truly making remembering one's whereabouts or actions an irretrievable memory? No doubt, Rudy Guede had sex with Meridith Kercher (and likely took her life) There's a lot that goes unexplained: the missing cell phone & money...and the loads of lies told in the beginning.

33171387
Flag this comment

hebeshebewebe said on December 6, 2009 at 4:18 AM

She was found guilty, she did it ,she must pay for it. And I am visiting Italy in 2010 and I think this verdict is GREAT.

33182407
Flag this comment

stormyweather said on December 6, 2009 at 11:36 AM

Looking at the grace and dignity of the Kercher family after losing a beautiful daughter in such tragic manner, it's rather embarrassing to look at the disgraceful, loud mouthed, insensitive, ethnocentric, delusional Knox clan.

33198577
Flag this comment