Print
Email
Share

Investigators: 'Special projects' bring lucrative perks for ferry workers

by SUSANNAH FRAME / KING 5 News

Bio | Email | Follow: @SFrameK5

KING5.com

Posted on March 29, 2010 at 9:45 PM

Updated Monday, Mar 29 at 9:45 PM

SEATTLE - Some workers in the cash-strapped ferry system are collecting thousands of dollars to drive to and from work, simply because their job is deemed a "special project."

Special projects at the Washington State Ferries are important assignments which keep boats moving and passengers safe. The projects include work such as training deck hands, developing vessel maintenance programs, and making sure engineers are up to speed on the latest technologies.

RELATEDEmployees boost pay by driving to work

Workers on special projects, about 40 ferry employees at any given time, usually have to travel away from their home terminal to their assignment. For the inconvenience, the state pays their travel time and mileage to drive or ride a ferry to and from work to get the job done.

Brian Twietmeyer has to shove off from his home terminal of Kingston and travel all the way to an office building in downtown Seattle for his special project. It’s a 24 mile round trip every day. His job is to make sure ferry deck hands are properly trained by developing their educational programs.

Last year, Twietmeyer made roughly $98,000 in wages. He earned an additional $26,000 for travel and mileage to get to and from the office. The travel benefit brought his total pay to $124,000 in 2009.

Many people would define a special project as something out of the ordinary; a job with a beginning and an end that lasts a few months or so. KING 5 has found the ferry system has a loose definition of special project. In some cases, they last 10 to 15 years. And as long as a job is slated a special project, taxpayers are funding the perks that go along with them.

Twietmeyer's been developing those deck hand training programs since 1999. For the last 12 years, he's been paid to travel to and from the same office five days a week. Based on available data obtained from the ferry system through a public records disclosure request, the KING 5 Investigators estimate Twietmeyer’s been paid about $220,000 in travel time and mileage over the years.

Sen. Curtis King, R-Yakima, sits on the Transportation Committee, which is painfully aware of the ferry system's dire financial picture. It’s facing a $1 billion shortfall over the next 15 years.

"When you've been doing something for 12 years, that's not a special assignment, that's an employee," said King. "We can't continue to pay the kinds of money you've shown me here today unless there's truly justification to do it, and on face value, it doesn’t appear that there would be."

Some workers have collected even more. Bill Hughes is a top-rated radar specialist. His job is to develop new radar technology and training programs. His work has been deemed a special project for the last 15 years.

Since 1995 the state's paid him for traveling to and from his home base in Bremerton. KING 5 estimates Hughes has received $450,000 in travel time and mileage over the years.

Why would some jobs be deemed a special project for so long, netting the workers lucrative benefits? Ferry executives tell us union contracts have historically been interpreted to mean those workers are entitled to the job classification and the travel perks.

But because of our investigation, that could be changing.

“Our goal will be to eliminate travel time and mileage for the two unions who currently have that in their contract," said David Moseley, Assistant Secretary for Washington State Ferries.

Moseley’s been running the ferry system for just two years. He said his first priorities were to cut out administrative overhead and millions of dollars in consultant contracts. Moseley said he wasn’t aware of the long-standing perks for special project employees until KING 5 started asking questions.

"The reality is your public disclosure request focused me on this issue," said Moseley.

The ferry employee who’s made the most through special projects is Michael O’Connor. He is highly skilled with a big job of preparing and updating dozens of technical training and operational manuals for the ferry system.

O'Connor's been traveling from his home base in Anacortes to a regional ferry office in Everett to work on this special project for 12 years. Last year, in time and mileage alone, he made nearly $50,000. Over the years, KING 5 estimates that benefit has added up to about $480,000; all that money for him to drive everyday to and from the exact same office.

Asst. Secretary Moseley says he should held accountable.

"I'm in charge of the ferry system. We have to fix this problem and we will,” said Moseley. “We must find a way to provide this important work cheaper, and we will."

KING 5 tried several times to reach the special project employees through their union chiefs, but calls and e-mails were not returned.

Print
Email
Share

To add a comment, please register or login.

1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Comments: Displaying 1 - 15 of 37

clint69975146227 said on June 21, 2010 at 1:03 PM

ya sailorinthesound, like thats gonna happen.....lmao. YOUR state negotiator (I.E MANAGEMENT) negotiated these terms. sure, you could waist more of washingtons (oh, excuse me, YOUR money) and take the employees to a court of law, but you would loose. it was bargained for and approved by both sides... get a clue

45852948
Flag this comment

sailorinthesound said on June 20, 2010 at 9:32 AM

Let's cut to the chase on this. All you have to do is ask yourself: "Would I run a business like this?" I bet the truthful answer would always be: HECK NO! These "practices" go way beyond the term "accountability" and is sugar coating these actions. If this was happening in my business, I would call it what it is: EMBEZZLEMENT. And because these are state funds, this is MY money going to these employess that have found very cleaver ways of obtaining money illegally! I would love to see some legal action taken against all the employees up and down the line that have participated in these actions. They should be fired on the spot and then held accountable in a court of law.

45786019
Flag this comment

jaimeretief said on June 6, 2010 at 1:14 AM

The vessels may be "decades old" but they receive regular technological upgrades to their propulsion and power generation systems. Would you like a short course in programmable logic controllers so that we can explain it to your satisfaction?

44811719
Flag this comment

rippedoff said on May 17, 2010 at 9:46 PM

Clint, You seem to be posting very loudly on all these issues claiming very adamantly that Moesley and Hammond knew all about it. Please share how you know this. Do you have facts? I am sure Susannah would like to know.

43415793
Flag this comment

avocats said on May 14, 2010 at 10:15 PM

"The projects include work such as training deck hands, developing vessel maintenance programs, and making sure engineers are up to speed on the latest technologies." These boats are decades old---why are they paid to "develop" maintenance programs? Didn't they figure this out like 50 years ago? And bringing engineers up to speed on latest technologies? Which ones, exactly? Again, those boats have been around for decades, what "new" technologies being used? I think it's time to hire more ferry workers so that these poor over-worked engineers can work 40 hours a week and let someone else can earn a living.

43270739
Flag this comment

clint69975146227 said on May 13, 2010 at 11:33 AM

YA RIGHT, DAVID MOSLEY DIDNT KNOW ABOUT THIS,,,,HA HA FOR DAVID MOSLEY TO SAY HE DIDNT KNOW ABOUT THIS, IS LIKE, PAULA HAMMOND TO SAY THAT SHE DIDNT KNOW ABOUT THIS......LMAO ITS NOT THE WORKERS FAULT, ITS MANAGEMENT

43164309
Flag this comment

jaimeretief said on May 7, 2010 at 6:37 PM

monquehaus - how many special projects have you applied for?

42813827
Flag this comment

seanav said on April 16, 2010 at 2:18 PM

I have known and worked with Captain Hughes for several years and know him to be one of the hardest working people in the fleet. He is on call 24/7 and often works weekends. He takes few vacations. His responsibilities include keeping the fleet up to date on the latest technologies (many Coast Guard required) not only in Radar but in developing products that improve the effectiveness of the operations of the fleet. Remember that the fleet operates vessels from Tacoma to Sidney, BC and he is responsible for the electronics on all of those vessels. He also teaches safety classes to the crewmembers—in other words Captain Hughes wears many hats, and has many projects that he works on at one time. Rather than come down on a very hard working individual, it might be better to look at the system within which he works. And, incidentally, I don’t believe that Captain Hughes has lived in Bremerton for 15 years—it’s only been a few years since he moved there.

41417912
Flag this comment

david_mack said on April 12, 2010 at 9:56 PM

WSF isn't going to "really" cut Special Projects travel time/mileage. They are going to create a "Special Projects" wage within the bargaining unit. If KING5 would do their proper research & file a Freedom of Information act concerning this item you would have already found this out. So figure $47 an hour for Capt wages, divide the 2 hours a day in travel which is $11.75 then add it to the exsisting wage of $47 $11.75 = new wage of $58.75 "Super" Special Projects Wage or SSPW in the MOU. You do know WSF has a Union within themselves for the Good 'ole Boys club members that includes Special Projects ?? F.A.A.S.P.A.

41147502
Flag this comment

monquehaus said on April 6, 2010 at 7:46 PM

"Spoken like a true VRE labor faking SCE wannabe. Reads like one of your idiotic proposals." Say what? Care to elaborate? I can't follow you.

40773619
Flag this comment

jaimeretief said on April 3, 2010 at 4:25 PM

Spoken like a true VRE labor faking SCE wannabe. Reads like one of your idiotic proposals.

40598932
Flag this comment

monquehaus said on April 1, 2010 at 9:54 PM

Given that our State is facing a budget deficit it only makes sense that the State is looking to curb expenditures. Another given is that a lot of Washington people are out of work, and hence this type of investigation tends to stigmatize the majority of the workers of the Ferry System. What the news spot doesn't convey is that the people working both in the Office and working under the Boat contract are in the minority. It is a small group of people making the 'System as a whole look bad. The majority of the wage earners in the Ferry System get paid for work performed, only make travel time and mileage when the boat is away from it's home terminal, and use their Ferry Pass to travel to the various Ship Yards during Annual and semi-Annual maintenance periods. In my opinion people on Special Projects should after a period of time, say 3 months, be on a leave of absence (LOA). This would include a LOA from Union's Contract, and a transition into Salaried work for a for Management.

40500754
Flag this comment

rationalthinking said on March 30, 2010 at 5:47 PM

Travel time is typically paid in many sectors of the Transportation Industry. To suggest that ferry workers should not receive travel pay, due to their employment by the state, is naive. The Ferry System operates inspected vessels that are legally mandated to carry a specified compliment of qualified crew members. The wages received by the vessel crews are commensurate with their ratings, although lower than the industry standard. Travel pay is factored in during contract negotiations and is considered as a portion of average, or overall, pay rather than an adjunct. This "fluff" investigation fails to accurately enlighten. In lieu of an attempt at sensationalizing the cost incurred to the state, for how much the employees are paid, it should be asking how much it will cost the state if they are NOT paid. Perhaps the management of the Ferry System's SMS should be farmed out to Det Norske Veritas or the American Bureau of Shipping. No problem, just add some zeros.

40343779
Flag this comment

ka7frz6375452367 said on March 30, 2010 at 5:06 PM

Today I watched, for the 2nd time, your report on the ferry system’s financial problems. You make it appear that the employees are “milking” the system to get the extra benefits and pay. This is not the case as you would have found out if you had done a reasonable amount of research. The glaring errors in your report are not errors of fact but errors of omission. The employees did not bargain the union contract but they are legally bound to abide by the provisions of that agreement. A collective bargaining agreement is a legal contract between the union and the company. You make it look like the employees are at fault. The employees are complying with the union contract. Would you have them violate their own contract? The fault here is the language in the contract and in the WSF policy manuals. Your logic is as faulty as your reporting. Get it right or shut up.

40341944
Flag this comment

rationalthinking said on March 30, 2010 at 4:57 PM

I don't see too much investigation in this alleged investigation. State workers are routinely paid for traveling to special assignments. The only difference is that some are paid to travel outside of their regular 8 hour shifts and some are paid to travel within them. ( i.e. they travel in a car or van pool to and from the assignment within their shift.) Therefore, if they travel for 3 hours per day they only work for 5 hours, at their assigned location. The assignments in question would be the equivalent of the Ferry System's Special Projects. It is my understanding that most county and city employees receive the same "perks." An unfortunate, possibly libelous, moniker. A "perk" is a gratuity, tip, or tribute outside of negotiated, contractual wages. The bumpkin from Boeing is paid to drill the same hole, over and over again. He is not a United States Coast Guard licensed Master or Chief Engineer.

40341564
Flag this comment

pugetsoundfan said on March 30, 2010 at 4:52 PM

I agree with those that say that management is the cause of these cost overruns. It's easy to throw stones at the unions, but everyone needs to remember that contracts are give and take. Unions and administrators often give up one thing to get a better situation in another. Another thing that K5 should investigate is how the pilots and others are given overtime pay. For instance, if three positions need to be filled throughout the system, the next up on the OT list has a choice of job and location. If you live in Edmonds and the Tahlequah-Tacoma runs needs an OT...you get paid to drive to Tacoma to catch the ferry. Why would you take a close one? It's poor management people...and easily fixable through negotiation (then again...what did the union give up to get that deal?) We need more information to jump to conclusions.

40341367
Flag this comment

sirbobby98121312 said on March 30, 2010 at 4:49 PM

According to the calc program on my pc...1999 to 2010 is 11 years... If you get the simple things wrong, it makes one wonder what other errors there are.

40341252
Flag this comment

sunlover said on March 30, 2010 at 11:29 AM

This has always been a benefit of the unions. I once said it was abuse, but it is not. The UNIONS definitely USE it and the management officials have allowed the ABUSE of it. For MOSELEY to say he didn't know about this after two years is preposterous. All of his direct reports knew about it and continued to authorize and support it. What is even more fantastic is that MOSELEY said he will have it taken away. I think that has been tried for decades. For these positions he would have to hire a person and then you wouldn't need a special project. I am wondering why most of these can't be done within the employees to date! Clearly upper level management has known and continued to allow for these special long term projects utilizing union members which in turn benefits their current pay check and their future retirement pay check.

40322737
Flag this comment

dea3761 said on March 30, 2010 at 9:09 AM

I wonder how many "special Projects" our elected officials get paid for? Not including all the lunches we the taxpayers pay for them. I'd bet we pay there way to and from work, to and from Olympia, to and from WA. D.C.

40313242
Flag this comment

joel4 said on March 30, 2010 at 8:48 AM

King 5. Seriously, if you are going to try investigative journalism, you should also investigate the buildings in your own neighborhood. I thought it funny that the office building in downtown Seattle you showed on your report that Brian Twietmeyer has been travelling to for 12 years is actually a condo building that my friend lives in and is only 18 months old. The "same office" for 12 years ha? And this building is only a stones throw from the King 5 studio. You should send that camera crew back for another stint on Snoqualmie pass.

40311667
Flag this comment

gotama said on March 30, 2010 at 7:52 AM

Bobknows please get your facts straight cause that isn't how it works

40307452
Flag this comment

rasko said on March 30, 2010 at 7:50 AM

The amount of money paid for travel time over the 12 year span is at first sight alarming. $480,000 is a big number which immediately grabs viewers' attention. This expense is currently a part of the cost of an expansive operation which relies on skilled employees assigned to locations throughout the system. A quick breakdown shows $40,000 per year, $3200 per month, or $160 per day being paid out for travel time to and from the employee's assigned location. Considering the hourly rate breakdown for a highly skilled employee plus a fuel allowance, this number is far less sensational. When King5 news deploys assets to Snoqualmie pass to report that snow is falling, talent, staff, equipment and fuel costs occur with each trip. What is the hourly rate breakdown for a medium market television news reporter, producer and engineer with satellite truck? The state ferry system serves citizens and tourists, and taxpayers have a stake in it. Managing costs is essential, but so is context.

40307293
Flag this comment

king5badreporter said on March 30, 2010 at 7:37 AM

always the unions fault? Why isn't anyone asking why management allowed this to go on so long? Lots of good comments here people are finally realizing its not always the workers that cause these problems

40306329
Flag this comment

jack747 said on March 30, 2010 at 7:20 AM

Even from Edmonds to downtown Seattle it is a 34.8 mile round trip so if Brian is only being paid for 24 miles than the citizens of Washington are getting a 'good deal'!

40305003
Flag this comment

a6chris said on March 30, 2010 at 6:48 AM

and yet the frowinng faced, overbearing, authoratative deckhands as you are loaded aboard - like they are doing you a favor... customer service is not in thier vocabulary. Granted they put up with the public all day - but so do alot of us. I drive from Whidbey Island ot Tukwila everyday and Boeing does not reimburse me for milage - nor would I expect them to! it is my choice to cimmuet the distance. They do allow telecommuting one day a week. Speaking of unions... yep... Back in the day when my Dad worked on the boats, mostly Edmonds - Kingston- they were busy all day - chippin rust, painting, cleaning etc, they did not just get the cars loaded and go hide out in a room until the boat docked. They also had to travel at times to fill in somewhere and were not paid to do so. Of course this was teh 60's -and into the early 70's. Other times they stayed onbaord all night to take it out first thing in the morning and wrer not paid any extra for remaining onboard overnight.

40302627
Flag this comment

lucyred said on March 30, 2010 at 6:35 AM

Why cannot the Governor realize that in trying to balance the budget she needs only to look at state employees perks!!!!!!!!!!

40301752
Flag this comment

bobknows said on March 30, 2010 at 6:11 AM

Ferry system jobs have always been awarded as political favors. They go to friends and relatives of major contributors to the Governor. Its a way for the Governor to pay off supporters with our money.

40299777
Flag this comment

tugthug said on March 30, 2010 at 6:09 AM

Here is another perk they get, they get to ride the ferry for FREE! from their homes in Bremerton and Kingston to their offices in Seattle. Wow! you gotta love these guys!

40299663
Flag this comment

speedracer said on March 30, 2010 at 5:34 AM

ahhh unions......

40296893
Flag this comment

firefoxtwo said on March 30, 2010 at 4:00 AM

while you look at the ferry system... take a look at the folks at light rail, as well. The city, state, and King County need to take a close look at this "feather bedding" going on. More taxes is not the answer. Better Managment is. If they don't perform get new ones.

40289239
Flag this comment

javajoe said on March 30, 2010 at 1:55 AM

Are you saying the government isn't running a program efficiently? What's the world coming to?

40285133
Flag this comment

wolfdaaawg said on March 30, 2010 at 12:09 AM

Are they going to pay the money back? I don't mind someone making a decent living .It's more the way they went about it .This must be generaly accepted practice if it went on for so many years.Is there no oversight?perhaps the overseers' were in on it also? Wow a special project for 12 years?This does'nt look too good for who ever was in charge.If it was reported as their wages I probably would not care. ..but taxpayers money???

40282733
Flag this comment

gotama said on March 30, 2010 at 12:00 AM

maybe someone should look into how management runs things they probably approve all these special projects ,and is also to my understanding that there are more in management now then there ever was , the ferry's have the same amount of personal crewing the vessels , yet the management still grows . if the state wanted to save a buck they should look at the number of jobs being wasted in over-management (ie micro-management )

40282514
Flag this comment

piloty2k said on March 29, 2010 at 11:30 PM

i have to agree with swat85, there is a lot more people higher up who is responsible for this. and i suspect that they also are over paid and taking advantage of loop holes created for them or by them. A couple of years ago it was exposed that most of the people working in Olympia got paid gas allowances and most of them drove large gas eating cars at the tax payers expense when fuel prices were hitting 5.00 a gallon. Where's the follow up news on this ? Are they still getting away with this ? As far as we know nothing has changed. If were going to start jumping on the little guy ripping off the system. Lets start at the top. What happened to Polsi and her larger Jets she tried to get? Did she still get them at our expense?

40281442
Flag this comment

gotama said on March 29, 2010 at 11:06 PM

If they are working in the office and not on the boat then they shouldn't be covered by the rules in the contracts for the employees that are working the boats , this just makes the ones that do work hard look bad .

40280943
Flag this comment

jppatches said on March 29, 2010 at 10:47 PM

swat, what's posting a pic gonna do? nothing? These people got busted. Who ever came up with this idea didn't look at the whole pic. I'm not sure if they had a home base they would work from if they weren't doing their special projects. Their home base should have been where their special projects were and they shouldn't have gotten travel pay.

40280679
Flag this comment

swat85 said on March 29, 2010 at 10:32 PM

If I'm not mistaken, these employees are under contract. If that contract gives them this extra compensation maybe we should look closer at the people or bodies that approved the contract? I think it is excessive but it if is negotiated then we need to look at the negotiators, not the employees. Let's post the pictures of the people that approved these contract positions rather than the employees who are probably following the rules. Whether we think they desreve it or not. Steve Watt

40280362
Flag this comment

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?

Register Now

Member Benefits

Link your account to your Twitter or Facebook account for easier login!

Link your account to your Facebook profile Link your account to your Twitter profile

Check box to receive Free Special Offers

* - Indicates required field

Check box to receive Free Special Offers

Connecting to

You may need to allow pop up window for this step of registration

Just one more step:

Please take a moment to review the available e-mail newsletters has to offer. Place a checkbox next to the newsletters you wish to subscribe to.

Welcome.

Thank you for becoming a member of KING5.com. You now have full access to the best local coverage and late breaking news from KING5.com. Soon you will be redirected to the page you were seeking, and a confirmation email will be delivered to you.

You will need to respond to the confirmation e-mail for your account to be activated.

KING5.com is dedicated to bringing you exceptional news and outstanding information services, all while personalizing it to your liking. We're sure you'll enjoy being a KING5.com member! If you need assistance, please contact us.