Print
Email
Share

Ferry system saves millions in labor costs

by SUSANNAH FRAME / KING 5 News

Bio | Email | Follow: @SFrameK5

KING5.com

Posted on March 16, 2011 at 10:44 PM

OLYMPIA, Wash. -- Washington State Ferries (WSF) is cutting out some fat. 

The cost of paying employees, which is the agency's biggest budget item, went down last year by $2.5 million. Financial records obtained by KING 5 Investigators show some of the savings were found in overtime, travel time, mileage pay and penalty pay.

"I think our employees want to be part of the solution," said David Moseley, Director of WSF. “I think we're on the right path to turning the system, to turning the tide."

Over the last year, the KING 5 Investigators' series "Waste on the Water" revealed systemic wasteful spending at WSF. The reporters exposed some time sheets loaded with excessive, self-assigned overtime. The money was paid to a group of staff chief engineers who are in charge of the engine rooms, located below deck on each vessel. Records showed their managers weren’t questioning the overtime.

After those stories aired the ferry system put together the agency’s first ever overtime policy. It’s working.

In 2009, the 22 staff chief engineers made a total of $532,976 in overtime. Last year the number fell to $426,532, which is a savings of $106,444.

The staff chief engineer of the ferry Walla Walla, Bruce Cooper, pulled in $58,000 in overtime in 2009. He made the most overtime of any staff chief engineer that year. In 2010 Cooper made $18,000 in overtime.

Overtime throughout the system went down by about $1 million.

"I think we've clearly done a better job of managing our overtime costs," said Moseley.

The KING 5 investigation also found the state paid a small number of employees to drive to and from work, to the same exact office, sometimes for years on end, because their jobs were labeled "special projects." The travel pay went back at least 30 years. Ten days after that story aired, WSF cut off the benefit.

That saved taxpayers about $100,000 last year. In the future, it should save the state more than $340,000 a year.

The most travel pay is made by relief workers. They’re paid to drive to and from work because they fill-in, sometimes at the last minute, to cover shifts when someone is sick or on vacation.

Last year, KING 5 found some relief workers worked the system by traveling as much as possible to make as much as possible. The practice was allowed under their contract with the Inland Boatman’s Association.

In 2009, some relief workers tacked on $35,000, $40,000, and in one case $72,000 in travel pay by choosing to work routes far from their homes. Total travel pay to relief workers in 2009 came to $3,184,918. The amount dropped in 2010 to $2,939,577. That’s a savings of $245,341.

Among all ferry employees, travel time and mileage pay dropped by nearly $500,000 from 2009 to 2010.

"I think that clearly, some light was shown, and I think some different decisions were being made because of the light being shown," said Moseley.

Currently, lawmakers are considering ferry reform bills in both the House and Senate. If they pass, labor costs are expected to go down significantly.

At the same time, ferry union members are voting on newly negotiated contracts. If ratified by members, the governor says that would save the state $10 million a year.

Print
Email
Share
 

To add a comment, please register or login.

1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Comments: Displaying 1 - 15 of 16

prestolog said on March 31, 2011 at 11:18 AM

Bigblue wrote: "We need to get government out of the operations of state owned businesses and let professionals run these." Ha ha. Boy have you been living under a rock! State ferry workers are not unlike airline employees and deserve the same respect. Airline pilots and flight engineers are in unions, as are cabin attendants, ground crews, mechanics, and maintenance personnel, which can well defend the case for having unions. So what do you believe a captain responsible for 200 human lives and a multi-million dollar aircraft / vessel should earn? Figure into that how much the support crews and their unique responsibilities should be paid? You obviously don't understand the situation at all.

63830938
Flag this comment

nonclassical said on March 29, 2011 at 9:20 AM

Ms. "Blame" continues to DISinform. Speaking of Staff Chief Engineer whose travel and mileage over one year "appear" exhorbitant, she neglects to supply his previous year's data, nor any explanation involving lengthy vessel repair Mr. Cooper was required to oversee. Rather, Ms. "Blame" contrives appearances of longstanding egregious, very nearly profiteering, which in actuality is what "investment banks" have done to destroy the U.S. economy; and which she has never exposed. What we see now, after Wisconsin, Indiana, Michigan attacks on labor, fully defines agenda driven reporting such as this. For those who wish to comprehend truth regarding economic malfeasance, read Yves Smith's, "ECONned". Ms. Smith is much more informed, and informative, than what we get here.

63657372
Flag this comment

THEFRAMEJOB said on March 23, 2011 at 6:04 PM

You removed my comments. You don't investigate well or tell the truth well.

63301552
Flag this comment

prestolog said on March 20, 2011 at 1:37 AM

Privatizing the ferries will not save any money at all. How do you figure that? This is whipping a dead horse, it's been looked into several times and found conclusively by various panels and consultants that it just isn't viable, so get over it! A private company has to turn a profit, and in doing so will ask for and receive a very healthy subsidy. And even in the remote chance it did become privatized, the same crews and unions would be manning them. What a lot of people don't realize is that the staff chiefs actually do EARN their money. I challenge anyone to walk in a staff chief's shoes for six months and then claim they are overpaid. Ha ha. Critics albeit are somewhat of a necessary evil, but the criticism must have merit. What Ms. Frame omitted in her latest attack on a staff chief was that he oversaw two extensive Eagle Harbor yard periods, one dry docking, and one eight-week dock side maintenance evolution. That type of schedule was unique due to circumstances.

63076181
Flag this comment

MrMadMac said on March 18, 2011 at 3:02 AM

think it a little to late they scam money and did not pay it back or goverment is out of controll and needs to be stop replace all the people and try again. waste of money will not be put up with.

62964984
Flag this comment

bricsa09 said on March 17, 2011 at 9:55 PM

It's great to see that these managers can accomplish cost savings, too, and even better that this gets into the news. Maybe that will encourage others in the public sector to do similarly.

62960356
Flag this comment

nolocomechanic said on March 17, 2011 at 6:43 PM

Hey Bigblue, great idea, get rid of those unions and save all that money. The problem is, who will run the vessels? The guys from "Deadliest Catch"and the rest of the fishing fleet don't have the credentials that would allow them to run the boats,engine or deck. You can't bring people in from off the street to run the vessels, so where are you going to get the deck and engine crews from? Additionally, if transportation/ferries was a venture that was capable of making money, then it would be privatized. Simple fact is passengers do not pay enough to keep up with the cost of fuel and ordinary maintenance.

62952211
Flag this comment

nolocomechanic said on March 17, 2011 at 6:37 PM

Hey King5, what is the purpose of stating peoples names, wages and putting up their pictures when you admit they haven't done anything wrong? It sure seems like this is personal.

62951906
Flag this comment

zaxxon7469 said on March 17, 2011 at 5:07 PM

What about the maintance overtime you guys blew the whislte on. You only mention by name one chief engineer on the Walla Walla, by not charging 40K more in Over time, what about the other boats. You never did prove if the maintenace OT was official or just padded. Don't get me wrong, I like that thee has been some oversite added to a state agency, and saving some money, but what about the big shots what do they make, and is it a RCW allowed wage or not. What kind of travel reimbursment are these workers getting. Federaly it is .50 cents a mile. are they getting more than that?

62948161
Flag this comment

bigblue1518 said on March 17, 2011 at 11:22 AM

Get rid of the unions and save 10X that amount. These nickle and dime improvements when we are millions in debt is lame. The entire system needs revamped from top to bottom and privatized. We need to get government out of the operations of state owned businesses and let professionals run these.

62927317
Flag this comment

jcman said on March 17, 2011 at 9:37 AM

freedomfrankz: Yeah let's privatize now so CEOs can make all that money instead of the working stiffs. CEOs don't spend the millions they get and that keeps it out of the economy and doesn't create jobs. Working stiffs spend their money which creates more and better jobs for everyone. One of the major problems with big Capitalism is it takes the money out of circulation.

62919716
Flag this comment

clear2copy said on March 17, 2011 at 8:51 AM

soo..will they be lowering the ticket prices..reflecting these 'savings'? ...ya.. didn't think so.

62916408
Flag this comment

austins381 said on March 17, 2011 at 7:00 AM

$3,000,000 saved...$6,999,700,000 to go.

62907643
Flag this comment

freedomfrank said on March 17, 2011 at 5:08 AM

In 2009, some relief workers tacked on $35,000, $40,000, and in one case $72,000 in travel pay by choosing to work routes far from their homes. Total travel pay to relief workers in 2009 came to $3,184,918. The amount dropped in 2010 to $2,939,577. That’s a savings of $245,341." So the fat lazy union thugs are still stealing from us and we're supposed to be happy??? Privatize now!!!!

62901527
Flag this comment

alysonkoch said on March 17, 2011 at 12:39 AM

Very Interesting! I just now printed Coupons of my Favorite Brands for free from "Printapons" you can find them online.

62896269
Flag this comment

matthias said on March 16, 2011 at 11:19 PM

Good job WSF and good job King5.

62895222
Flag this comment