Print
Email
Share

Head of Madigan removed from command during PTSD probe

by MEG COYLE / KING 5 News

KING5.com

Posted on February 21, 2012 at 9:13 AM

Updated Tuesday, Feb 21 at 8:01 PM

TACOMA, Wash. -- Two top administrators at Madigan Army Medical Center are on suspension as the government investigates how the hospital screens soldiers for PTSD.
 
At least 14 local soldiers had their diagnoses changed. All are appealing, and could find out the results tomorrow, including Army Specialist Jared Enger.
 
In the fall of 2010, doctors diagnosed Enger with PTSD. But a year later, a doctor who had never treated him, reversed the diagnosis. "So I was sitting in an inpatient hospital talking to a doctor on the phone trying to dispute the fact they said I didn't have PTSD while I was in an inpatient program for PTSD diagnosis," recalled Enger.
 
Enger's case is one of 14 under review after a doctor at Madigan Army Medical Center claimed the soldiers weren't suffereing from PTSD at all.

"It was discounted, and that was it," said Enger.
 
Madigan's Commander, Col. Dallas Homas along with Dr. William Keppler, head of Madigan's forensic psychiatric team, are suspended while the Army Medical Command investigates whether they prioritized saving money over mental health.
 
At a purple heart ceremony Tuesday honoring Marine veteran Kenneth McAllister with a purple heart, Senator Maria Cantwell said she's anxious for answers.

"Getting access to care is the most important thing and so we're going to make sure that happens," said Sen. Cantwell.
 
Soldiers diagnosed with PTSD are awarded a 50 percent rating of disability and qualify for pensions, family health insurance, and other financial benefits.

Print
Email
Share
 

To add a comment, please register or login.

1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Comments: Displaying 1 - 15 of 23

LexiAF535 said on March 3, 2012 at 6:20 PM

Some of these psychiatrists and psychologists have been paid by defense attorneys to diagnose civilian criminals with PTSD to help get shorter sentences or get the charges dismissed altogether. Maybe these cases should be looked in to also. It's just as likely that they are misdiagnosing these criminals because the defense is paying them. Obviously they are easily persuaded by money.

82949806
Flag this comment

firstlisten62 said on February 22, 2012 at 6:42 AM

This story is not surprising to me, because I’ve lived it myself. Our current soldiers should not have to continue going through the injustices I went through. Those top-officials in charge today, who continue to allow past wrongs to not be reversed once they are made aware of them, are just as culpable as those who initially wronged these soldiers. To turn a blind eye, once you are in a position to correct a continued wrong, is just as wrong as those who initially started this train wreck, because you become an accessory to the crime, as a result of your obstruction of justice for these wronged veterans. There is no arguing your way out of accountability for this egregious harm to those sacrificing so much for all of us.

81894944
Flag this comment

firstlisten62 said on February 22, 2012 at 6:42 AM

Unfortunately, I was unable to retain any type of employment, due to my mental and physical disabilities, which had gotten worse through time. My body finally broke down, resulting in more surgeries due to my military disabilities and as a result of having back-breaking jobs due to overt institutionalized racism and discrimination to veterans in general, which were acknowledged by the Social Security Department.

81894914
Flag this comment

firstlisten62 said on February 22, 2012 at 6:41 AM

I served as a US Marine and US Army soldier, then had to work two back-breaking jobs once discharged, in order to support my family, due to the government’s actions to cut costs for caring for veterans. I came home every other night, to sleep and then awake; having to go through the same schedule again, even with these disabilities I suffer through today. Many times, I broke down in private, because the VA refused to acknowledge my personal sacrifice of my body and my mind. I eventually, through a VA paid tuition, as a result of a 30% rating I successfully lobbied for after 10-years of fighting for my disability, got a Bachelors degree from the University of Washington in 2007. I thought this would solve everything, because now I could finally get a well-paid job.

81894834
Flag this comment

firstlisten62 said on February 22, 2012 at 6:41 AM

PTSD rejection from the VA, so what else is new? It took me more than 14-years to get my current VA rating and disability benefits, even though the Social Security Department psychiatrist; Virginia Mason Hospital; and Seattle Veteran’s Hospital psychologists and psychiatrists recognized that I do have PTSD. I currently pay out-of-pocket, for medications and treatment for this ailment, because the VA refuses to give me this rating because there is no exact date to assign for when my PTSD can be attributed too. This, I believe, is the area the government uses to manipulate (to control costs for having to pay for a soldier’s care- define) the definition of the accepted wording a soldier presents for his/her argument in lobbying for a PTSD rating. The government uses this mine-field, a veteran must negotiate after service to our country in order to get his/her embarrassing-yet-entitled-too rating, to cut costs as a result of this accepted responsibility for a veteran’s continued care.

81894814
Flag this comment

exphillydame said on February 22, 2012 at 4:51 AM

cont. the problem is, very few soldiers can get a TRUE DSM diagnosis of PTSD so most are diagnosed with 'traits of PTSD' such as depression and anxiety, insomnia, etc. veterans' benefits are designated for those with the DSM diagnosis. COMPLETELY and UTTERLY unfair! you would think that the easiest thing to do is to lobby for changing what is needed to qualify for that 50%. what they did to these soldiers going back and changing the diagnosis WITHOUT A FACE TO FACE, especially AFTER the diagnosis of PTSD was given is inacceptable and a complete CROCK. i really truly hope people can see how important it is we meet the needs of our returning soldiers! they make it possible for us to have what we have. a veteran should never have to worry about their basic needs such as medical/mental health care, housing, food, or clothing for the rest of their lives. we owe it to them.

81886874
Flag this comment

exphillydame said on February 22, 2012 at 4:44 AM

a soldier without a doubt does THE HARDEST JOB IN THE WORLD. for congress to cut the budget on our troops when they return home on their medical, ESPECIALLY mental health care, this is INEXCUSABLE. i would eagerly cough up an extra 10$ in taxes if i knew it went DIRECTLY to funding mental health care for the troops when they returned home. think about it.....every working person who pays taxes, the government collects an extra 10$ at tax time, forgive me if i don't have the actual numbers handy but it seems to me that would amass a large amount to go directly to these men and women who do SO MUCH FOR US!!!!! this is not about whether or not you are against the war, this is about the PERSON, the son or daughter, the mother or father, the best friend, the lover who is off fighting, only to come back and not have their needs met, sometimes their very basic needs such as housing because reintegration into civilian society is difficult after such trauma.

81886592
Flag this comment

delll said on February 21, 2012 at 11:24 PM

You people have to be kidding me. COL Homas wasn't even the commander when the PTSD program was integrated into the behavioral health dept. Before you cast judgement please do some reading. He has done nothing but good for our soldiers! I am upset they made him take leave during the investigation. I should point out that LTG Honcho was the regional commander at the time this happened...so this happened under her watch, not the current staff's!

81878382
Flag this comment

tenspeed said on February 21, 2012 at 3:52 PM

So we cut the benifits of the people whom have paid the price, just to save our tax money. Let me see this again... We also increase the eligibility for welfare by 42 percent, and those people may not be veterans but want a free ride because they are afraid to join the service or too lazy to work. This isn't a race issue. This is a tax dollar issue. Cut the welfare and increase the veterans benefits. Simple choice.

81850561
Flag this comment

Conseula said on February 21, 2012 at 2:36 PM

Another comment..How dare our government deny any soldiers medical help in order to save the tax payers money!! These men and women are fighting to keep us at home snuggled up in bed, our recliners, watching television safe..take the time to go on the internet and ask Google to give you a list of the amounts $$$ of "foreign aid" being sent to other countries, AND COUNTRIES THAT ARE NOT STRONG SUPPORTERS OF THE USA..ALONG WITH A FEW TERRORIST COUNTRIES RECEIVING FOREIGN AID...WHO PAYS FOR IT.."DIAGNOSIS" WE THE TAX PAYERS AND YOU HAVE THE AUDACITY TO QUIBBLE OVER OUR TAXES USED TO HELP THESE SOLDIERS WHO HAVE AND ARE FIGHTING FOR US SINCE 911!

81843512
Flag this comment

kewfly said on February 21, 2012 at 2:32 PM

Perhaps the answer is this: when Congress decides to send soldiers into harms way, set aside the funding for all the care PROMISED when they return. That would certainly (hopefully) make them think twice about sending our troops where they don't belong.

81843251
Flag this comment

Conseula said on February 21, 2012 at 2:29 PM

@clothyard..So you are saying that those few "bad apples" should deny the majority of "true" PTSD victims help? I have no idea, but a question to you? Your ship mates were killed due to a "on board" gun explosion..Whose fault was that? Do you really think that being on a ship in the Navy during the Vietnam war could compare to those foot soldiers doing hand to hand combat with the Vietnam soldiers? I thank you for your 30 years of service but find your comment to be cruel..These young soldiers fighting this ridiculous war are covering your a.. (like you did in your day) and fighting for you and our country..Dieing, blind, losing arms, legs, hearing, 3rd degree burns disfiguring them for life, etc. Now being on a battle ship during WW2 would be another story..

81842911
Flag this comment

zaxxon7469 said on February 21, 2012 at 2:07 PM

I am personally being denied benafits from the VA, because the burden of proof falls on the soldier to prove any ailments are service related. So my informed opinion,@Clothyard, is that when you finally get the VA and Military to to agree it is service connected, then they are responsable to take care of you. Not just be a bottom line. Could there be Gold Brickers out there, yes. Are these 14 soilders gold brikers, I'm not a head shrinker, but lets give them the benafit of a doubt.

81840984
Flag this comment

clothyard said on February 21, 2012 at 12:19 PM

O come on!. I spent 30 years on active duty, in the Navy including the entire Vietnam conflict area, lost 4 shipmates in an on board gun explosion, was fired on and HIT by NVA artillery (well not hit personally, the ship was) and none of my shipmates has PTSD. While I recognize that PTSD IS a legitimate condition in SOME instances, I strongly suspect that many many more are merely attempts to get something extra for nothing. My informed opinion is, the Madigan officials probably did their job too well and are being punished by the PC left anti war politicians who LOVE PTSD to bolster their anti-war (Actually anti self defense, pro world government, european style) politics. There is a core of PC politicians who are working very hard to emasculate ALL military organizations. Their goal, is a world incapable of defending itself from the rabble who riot in Greece, and occupy our city centers.

81829792
Flag this comment

kingster said on February 21, 2012 at 12:19 PM

"Minor oversight"???? It wasn't you that got screwed !

81829764
Flag this comment

backinmyday said on February 21, 2012 at 11:56 AM

He should have his medical license revoked. I agree, they could have included his rank or title, Colonel Dallas Homas or Dr. Dallas Homas.

81826844
Flag this comment

hewhoo said on February 21, 2012 at 11:52 AM

Komo news online even has the Colonel's picture in their story....

81826334
Flag this comment

hewhoo said on February 21, 2012 at 11:48 AM

I went after a fuller detail elsewhere: "Col. Dallas Homas’ leave was announced Monday evening by Maj. Gen. Phillip Volpe, who leads the Western Region Medical Command. Col. Mike Heimall, commander of Irwin Army Community Hospital, Fort Riley, Kan., is taking Homas’ place as interim commander." The Olympian still has reporters who remember the 5 W's most reputable J-schools used to teach.

81825841
Flag this comment

sir_kris said on February 21, 2012 at 11:33 AM

It sounds like this clown may have been directly responsible for instituting that ridiculous policy of reversing PTSD diagnoses to reduce costs. While I'm not certain that this would actually rise to the level of misconduct, at very least it does rise to the level of incompetence, in which case removing him from the post was the right call to make.

81823804
Flag this comment

sir_kris said on February 21, 2012 at 11:29 AM

While the comments are a bit harsh for such a minor oversight, I do agree with the overall point being made. The full name and rank really should be included in the article. It was probably just simple human error guys, but hopefully they'll correct it.

81823391
Flag this comment

kula280710781997 said on February 21, 2012 at 10:58 AM

If he had knowledge of this and allowed it.......I hope he is stripped of HIS retirement pension.

81819882
Flag this comment

1dljones said on February 21, 2012 at 10:38 AM

Does he have a rank? That is a strange name, but maybe he just forgot too add a ",". Pesky little things those comma's.

81817712
Flag this comment

invalid said on February 21, 2012 at 9:44 AM

"...announced Monday Homas has been removed from his position...." Is that the guy's name - Monday Homas? Is writing clearly really that difficult? Does anyone think to proofread stuff before sending it out on the wire to ensure that people like me won't have to ask stupid questions about what's written?

81810994
Flag this comment