Print
Email
Share

Amanda Knox trial blogger shut down

by MEG COYLE / KING 5 News

KING5.com

Posted on May 11, 2011 at 5:07 PM

Updated Wednesday, May 11 at 5:17 PM

New supporters begin to speak out as Amanda Knox fights to overturn her conviction for killing her British roommate. But a controversial prosecutor is silencing that support and using the Italian court to do it.

A man by the name of Frank Sfarzo is behind a popular website that's followed the Knox trial from the beginning.

But the website, Perugia-Shock.blogspot.com, has been shut down by a prosecutor with a growing appetite for silencing anyone who criticizes him

Sfarzo and head prosecutor Giuliani Mignini aren't exactly best friends.  A lone picture of the two of them is about as close as they may ever get.

Speaking via Skype, Sfarzo talked about a judge's order to shut down his popular website.

Sfarzo often criticized the justice system in Perugia, especially Mignini, a man Sfarzo says is growing more desperate as Amanda's appeal goes on. 

"He's already falling apart. There is nothing against Amanda and Raffaele, there remains nothing,” he said.

In a country that doesn't have the free speech protections we do, the prosecutor - Mignini - is suing Sfarzo for defamation.  He's not alone. He's just the latest in a growing list of people being sued or threatened by Giuliani Mignini.

There's Amanda Knox, already serving 26 years for killing Meredith Kercher, now charged with defaming the police by saying they hit her, called her a liar, and abused her during questioning.

Her parents Curt Knox and Edda Mellas were sued for repeating her daughter's claims.

American Crime Writer Doug Preston, another Mignini critic, who felt so threatened he fled Italy.

"In Italian, with no lawyer present, in which Mignini accused me of heinous crimes, demanded that I confess,” he said.

Mignini even threatened to sue westseattleherald.com and Steve Shay.

"It just didn't seem rational to quote somebody in context and then be slapped on the wrist by somebody 8,000 miles away,” said Shay.

Knox is appealing her murder conviction and 26-year sentence. Her case was given fresh hope earlier this year, when a judge appointed experts to re-examine the evidence against her.  But the prosecutor is also appealing, asking that Knox's sentence be increased to life in prison, which is allowed under Italian law.

Print
Email
Share
 

To add a comment, please register or login.

1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Comments: Displaying 1 - 13 of 13

hebeshebewebe said on May 16, 2011 at 9:36 AM

Why is king 5 taking this approach in this report. There is a mountain of evidence against seattles favorite convicted murderer. And because of a pr machine the minions of the foa continue to make noise but the facts remain. She cannot get past all her lies,all her story changes,DNA and physical evidence including cell phone records. King 5 should report news and actually dig into why Judge Mangini had to kabosh this liar Sfarzos blog. Reporting means Digging. King 5 Do Your Homework or you have no credibility.

67130953
Flag this comment

THEBARETHRUTH said on May 14, 2011 at 7:44 PM

Amanda Knox has written sexual murder stories. this fades her "Barbie Doll" image. What innocent person who was somewhere else would not say where they were? Who would hold back where they were in order to face decades in prison? What could she possibly have been doing that was worth spending years in prison rather than reveal? Also, it is not a spun story that Amanda Knox wrote sexual murder erotica. She has shown many times that she does not have empathy for other humans.

67071652
Flag this comment

barry_t said on May 13, 2011 at 7:17 PM

Prosecutor Magnini ought to heed the words of Edward R. Murrow, "To be persuasive, we must be believable. To be believable, we must be credible. To be credible, we must be truthful." While he dismisses Amanda's testimony about physical and mental abuse during the all nighter, the testimony of others affirm her truthfulness. That contrasts with his playing fast and loose with testimony such as lying about the Harry Potter novel at Raf's flat and spinning theories about sexual games, then twisting his story on summation to a hateful relationship when there was evidence of the opposite. Persecution of the reporter who recorded Magnini's lack of credibility will not make Magnini's misdeeds right..

67031752
Flag this comment

expatbrit said on May 13, 2011 at 5:13 AM

If you're planning on meeting Amanda Knox of her flight from Italy, you're gonna have to wait until sometime after 2025. Until she can tell the court when she spent the night and provide the evidence to back it up, she is staying put regardless of the DNA evidence. Mobile phone records prove she is lying as AK's phone was picked up at 9.30pm on a mast which was nowhere near Raffaele's apartment plus Raffaele still hasn't backed up her alibi. RS says AK left his apartment between 9pm-1am and he hasn't publically retracted this statement nor have his lawyers. RS has no plans to give evidence to the court so it's unlikely his story will change again. As for Frank Szfarzo, he accused the public prosecutor of being involved with drugs. He did this on his website which is defamation in Italy. Mignini correctly asked for the offending material to be removed and in response, Google Blogger dumped the whole thing. Hardly a victimisation campaign. Lazy journalism is lazy.

66982477
Flag this comment

ezekiel33 said on May 13, 2011 at 12:44 AM

Everything, including the DNA evidence, points to the jobless drifter Rudy Guede being the sole killer. He already had a rap sheet and threatened someone in a previous crime. He also told a roomate in prison, Knox didn't do it. Why would a highly intelligent college student like Knox, pretty and adventurous and hungry for advanced education living in a nice house w/a wonderful view of Italy, decide to kill her roomate and risk going to jail for a long time? It doesn't make sense. Same with her ex-boyfriend. Guede is a typical thug criminal with little or no desire for education.

66976139
Flag this comment

THEBARETHRUTH said on May 12, 2011 at 5:58 PM

Amanda Knox is a guilty psychopath. She has written sexual murder stories and has displayed much disturbing pathological behavior upon examination beyond the focus of an American media that says a beautiful girl cannot possibly be guilty. In the days of the internet, thankfully there is information about this murderer that is not part of the parent's endless publicity campaign to sway the truth. One does not blame the parents for trying, but wonders, what in Amanda's past made her want to write erotic sexual murder stories. One wonders why the American media continually leaves this point out along with many important details that prove she killed her room mate. Amanda Knox is America's Karla Homolka.

66961533
Flag this comment

gritz said on May 12, 2011 at 7:37 AM

Maybe if Amanda could remember where she was while her roommate was getting murdered, that would help.

66922339
Flag this comment

fwkc63 said on May 12, 2011 at 6:22 AM

I'm just glad I live in the USA!! Hey you egomaniac...it's called Freedom of Speach!! Deal with it!!

66916612
Flag this comment

Juan7 said on May 11, 2011 at 10:48 PM

Um, why hasn't King5 mentioned that Sfarzo's defamation was associating Mignini with drug dealing. King5's competitor MyNorthWest has done so. I think that any person - public official or not - has the right to defend themselves from such association and smearing if the blogger can offer no proof.

66904521
Flag this comment

cjcampbell said on May 11, 2011 at 10:18 PM

With no rule of law, where the powerful can silence dissent, it is no wonder that people lose respect for a legal system. And politicians wonder how things like the Mafia get started. It is a lesson and a warning to us all.

66903896
Flag this comment

WhoMe said on May 11, 2011 at 9:45 PM

The political system in Italy makes me ashamed to be of Italian decent. Just disgusting. And no big surprise that a prosecutor is about ego or more likely trying to move up the political ladder over the body of the innocent. You find that here too.

66903074
Flag this comment

dakotanative said on May 11, 2011 at 6:47 PM

Time for a group of Seals with recent terrorist experience to pay the prosecuter a visit.

66896069
Flag this comment

bazwest said on May 11, 2011 at 5:57 PM

Sounds like for the prosecutor this is not about justice it is about ego.

66893567
Flag this comment