Print
Email
Share

Beacon Hill attackers learn their fate

by KYLE MOORE / KING 5 News

KING5.com

Posted on July 30, 2010 at 4:45 PM

SEATTLE - For more than a year, one question has lingered in Dawit Alemu's mind.

"Why?" he says from the sofa of his families Beacon Hill apartment.

The victim spent months in a coma and nearly lost his sight. But some of his lingering questions may never be answered.

Last summer, the 26-year-old was brutally attacked outside his families home. The attack put Alemu in a coma for several months and almost caused one of his eyes to go blind.

"I am just mad they attacked me. I don't know why they attacked me. For what ?" asked Alemu.

The June 18, 2009 attack occurred just one day before Alemu was set to graduate from Seattle Central Community College. Alemu dreamed of heading to the University of Washington to complete his education. The attack has kept Alemu from his full-time security job and does not allow the son to take care of his deaf mother.

As a child, Alemu moved from Ethiopia where his family saw much hardship. He never thought he would be attacked in America outside his home.

In a sentencing hearing for two of the attackers, King County Deputy Prosecuting attorney Steven Kim compared Alemu's brain injuries to those of "Shaken Baby Syndrome." According to Kim, "he was in a coma, he was blind for a period of time and doctors were concerned he would never see again."

A witness took a photo of the attack which led to the arrest of three men. Police took into custody Justin Phillips, Jaynus Speed and Kenneth Fisher. A fourth man has not been arrested or charged.

Speed and Fisher appeared before a judge after they plead guilty to second-degree assault and first-degree attempted robbery.

Fisher's attorney, Ann Mahony, told a judge that Fisher was celebrating his 19th birthday and was "very drunk" and suffers from fetal alcohol syndrome. Mahony says the alcohol and brain injury led to the attack and Fisher is "not an irredeemable thug who is out... preying on individuals."

Fisher's father told a judge his son was "on the right track" and "nothing like this ever happened before."

"He is not a bad person," said Fisher's sister who was fighting back tears. "Before this, he has never been in any kind of trouble."

"The greatest sadness is reserved for Mr. Alemu for what he has gone through," said Speed's attorney Julie Gaisford.

Neither Speed nor Fisher spoke in court when given the opportunity.

Judge Laura Gene Middaugh called the crime "egregious" and said "Mr. Alemu, I wish I could tell you why this happen but I can't. That is why these cases are so frustrating."

Judge Middaugh sentenced Speed to three years in prison and Fisher to more than two and a half years behind bars.

Alemu didn't get his apology. Now he plans to move forward.

"I am just glad I recovered, I am not blind... I just want to go back to regular good things."

Print
Email
Share

To add a comment, please register or login.

1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Comments: Displaying 1 - 15 of 19

dkjamerican said on August 1, 2010 at 10:31 AM

We have become a plea dealing society instead of a law-biding society who expects justice. I don't care how drunk they were, they almost beat a man to death and the most they get is 3 years and don't be suprise if they are out in 6 months. I say take the blind fold off of lady justice and just decapitate her. They chose to drink & beat this man, end of story. and now people are saying the young men aren't responsible for their actions. Why lock anyone up, I am sure if you asked anyone in prison if the meant to do their crime, most would say no with a smile.

48956068
Flag this comment

rumin said on August 1, 2010 at 8:11 AM

I'm still curious as to the motive. The article does not make it very clear as to the actual reasons the perps felt compelled, drunk or not, to attack their victim with overwhelming odds.

48949929
Flag this comment

auburngirl said on July 31, 2010 at 1:15 PM

And by the way F. A. S. is not an excuse. People with this disability are not violant. They have impulse control issues to varing degrees. If they have extreme issues then they need supervision and guidence in which case he never should have been using alcohol or drugs. Where does the responsibilty lie ? I say with himself and his family. He should not have gotten less than the maxium punishment.

48914211
Flag this comment

auburngirl said on July 31, 2010 at 1:02 PM

Mr Alemu the justice system failed you. I am sorry. It seems like you are a strong person and I hope you are able to keep recovering and finish school. As for the sick brutal worthless lifetime crimminals that attacked you i HOPE THEY GET SHANKED IN PRISON. I want the time to fit the crime also. I believe if you attack someone for anything other than self defense your a danger to sociaty and should be locked up untell your to feeble to harm anyone ever again............... why do we except such violance ? let the evil people live with one another behind bars and give them food, water, and sharp sticks to play with.

48913699
Flag this comment

denkoko said on July 31, 2010 at 1:00 PM

NOT anywhere NEAR the prison time they should have to serve. NO WONDER Oregonians passed measure 11, which sets tough penaltys of 60 months for crimes of this nature that are MANDATORY. MOST courts are WAY to lenient in sentancing.

48913634
Flag this comment

taxed said on July 31, 2010 at 12:33 PM

Maybe the judge or DA will get attacked........Things whould change betcha.

48912654
Flag this comment

mlloyd said on July 31, 2010 at 10:28 AM

I think probation and counseling, like anger management and a victims awareness class would have been enough. Maybe throw in some NA meetings.

48907768
Flag this comment

pete33 said on July 31, 2010 at 10:12 AM

ACTUALLY THEY DESERVE THE DEATH PENALTY DUE TO THE VICIOUSNESS OF THE CRIME.

48907176
Flag this comment

pete33 said on July 31, 2010 at 10:08 AM

THIS SENTENCING IS A DESCPICABLE INSULT. YOU GET MORE TIME FOR SMOKING MARIJUANA. THESE USELESS, WORTHLESS THUGS SHOULD GET MINIMUM LIFE IN PRISON WITH THE KEY THROWN AWAY. THEY OUGHT TO BE LOCKED IN A DUNGEON AND THROWN IN WITH THE SODOMITES. 3 YEARS???? THA TIS WHAT IS WRONG WITH THIS SOCIETY. THEY WILL GET OUT AND DO THE SAME THING AND OUR POLITICIAN MORONS WILL THEN SAY WHY, GEE WHAT WENT WRONG? UNBELIEVABLE!

48907019
Flag this comment

aleigha said on July 31, 2010 at 9:46 AM

Whistleberries, I couldn't agree more. 3 yrs and 2 1/2 yrs hmmm so 1 1/2 yrs and 1 yr.... not to mention time served, for almost killing a person let alone the complete destruction it caused in the victims day to day life. Not being able to graduate, loss of employment, financial problems that ensued because of that, not being able to take care of his own mother in her situation and the hardship that created as well! Seems like the prosecutor's office was looking out for the criminals well being more than the victim's. That is the last and final piece of the crimes against this man and his family...and they ( the thugs) are such "good people" that they didn'y even have the personal integrity enough to apoligize for whatever it was worth!! ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE. My thoughts and prayers go out to this man and his family and I apoligize, and hope that this doesn't make him feel like all americans are that hateful..

48906024
Flag this comment

underserf said on July 31, 2010 at 7:56 AM

@whistleberries - yep, sentencing guidelines that treat a violent personal crime as worse than growing pot.

48901424
Flag this comment

glenh865 said on July 31, 2010 at 7:44 AM

They should be shot!

48900844
Flag this comment

cj_voges said on July 31, 2010 at 7:06 AM

2.5 years for this crime? No wonder this kind of crime is rampant! Life w/o parole sounds much better. I wish Dawit good luck in his schooling.

48898867
Flag this comment

jackwong said on July 31, 2010 at 4:45 AM

More people should be packin' heat.

48890993
Flag this comment

hendrake said on July 31, 2010 at 12:23 AM

Mr. Alemu, I am glad you have recovered and are not blind. Justice, on the other hand, is clearly blind...and stupid. With credit for time served and time off for 'good behavior,' these two thugs will be out next year.

48884324
Flag this comment

yogibear said on July 30, 2010 at 6:09 PM

Two thugs in the making.They are both bad people. Good people don't beat the living s@@t out of people.

48873138
Flag this comment

ballardgal said on July 30, 2010 at 5:53 PM

Someone who's "not a bad person" does not beat a total stranger within an inch of his life, I don't care how inebriated he was.. These two are getting away with attempted murder, basically. Monsters.

48872353
Flag this comment

whistleberries said on July 30, 2010 at 5:40 PM

Indeed, just a slap on the wrist. The time does not match the crime. Beating someone with an inch of their life should have a more meaningful consequence. Something like 20 to 30 years - with no early release - ought to be just about right. However, once again, apparently, we can point the finger at the State of Washington Sentencing Guidelines Commission, the legislature and the governor, for allowing such a light sentence for such an egregious crime. Ideally, they should have been able to apply for Social Security the first day of their release, only to discover they do not have enough work credits to collect anything.

48871588
Flag this comment

bazwest said on July 30, 2010 at 4:58 PM

A veritable slap on the wrist. The brutality of the crime suggest this was an attempt at murder. "He is not a bad person," just doesn't come across as believable under the circumstances.

48869799
Flag this comment

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account?

Register Now

Member Benefits

Link your account to your Twitter or Facebook account for easier login!

Link your account to your Facebook profile Link your account to your Twitter profile

Check box to receive Free Special Offers

* - Indicates required field

Check box to receive Free Special Offers

Connecting to

You may need to allow pop up window for this step of registration

Just one more step:

Please take a moment to review the available e-mail newsletters has to offer. Place a checkbox next to the newsletters you wish to subscribe to.

Welcome.

Thank you for becoming a member of KING5.com. You now have full access to the best local coverage and late breaking news from KING5.com. Soon you will be redirected to the page you were seeking, and a confirmation email will be delivered to you.

You will need to respond to the confirmation e-mail for your account to be activated.

KING5.com is dedicated to bringing you exceptional news and outstanding information services, all while personalizing it to your liking. We're sure you'll enjoy being a KING5.com member! If you need assistance, please contact us.