Print
Email
Share

Vaccine exemptions likely to be more difficult soon

by Jean Enersen

Bio | Email | Follow: @jeanenersen

KING5.com

Posted on April 16, 2011 at 10:00 AM

Updated Saturday, Apr 16 at 12:55 PM

Childhood vaccinations protect kids against a host of diseases, everything from measles to polio to tetanus.

"A lot of the things, threats that parents had to worry about, are gone. Immunization has made that possible," said Dr. Ed Marcuse, Associate Medical Director at Seattle Children's.

But fear of vaccine injuries, and suspected links to autism, have led a number of parents to reject vaccines for their children.

"There's mounting science-based evidence that there is no relationship between autism and vaccines," said Dr. Marcuse.

He said when parents opt their children out of vaccinations it puts whole communities at risk of outbreaks.

"No one wants to immunize anybody against their parent's will. What we want to make sure is that parents have access to good information," he said.

Dr. Marcuse favors new legislation that would add a step when parents opt their child out of required vaccinations for daycare and school.

Today all parents must do to opt out is sign an exemption. The new bill requires a signed form from a health care practitioner showing parents received information about vaccine risks and benefits.

Vashon Island resident March Twisdale, mother of two, objects to the approach.

"I don't love vaccines. They make me nervous on a number of levels. And I have a problem with the whole theory," Twisdale explained.

Both her sons have had whooping cough. She said they're now more immune to getting it again. And she said breast-feeding both of them as infants, and making sure they get plenty of sleep, boosts their immune systems against illness.

Twisdale raises her own chickens and gathers vegetables from her own garden. She said a nutritious organic diet helps her family's immune systems too.

Still, after careful research, she immunized her sons against some diseases, including diphtheria and tetanus. She opted out of other vaccines.
 
"It is just like so safe to get chickenpox. Are we designed to respond to tetanus? No. From my understanding, usually you die," she said, explaining her thinking on vaccine selection.

Dr. Marcuse doesn't expect a new law to change all parents' minds about vaccines, saying instead, he hopes it will spark discussion.

"Doctors like parents absolutely want to do what's best for a child."
 
The governor is expected to sign the new bill into law. It would then affect all families  enrolling new kids in childcare or school. The law would go into affect 90 days after the governor signed the bill.

Print
Email
Share
 

To add a comment, please register or login.

1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Comments: Displaying 1 - 5 of 5

mamadoc said on April 27, 2011 at 2:48 PM

I submitted a comment but it was never posted. I'd like to know why only the anti vaccine comments are being approved. This legislation is just trying to make sure parents get good information and not weird cyber information with no scientific backing. The article above alone is hilarious....comparing the remarks of Dr. Marcuse and this mom is just plain funny. But I guess some people prefer Jenny McCarthy to real science.

65904184
Flag this comment

dawnC said on April 20, 2011 at 6:33 PM

After my baby was injured by his 9 vaccines from birth - 6 mo of age (seizures and autism) I found out the following: My brother has documentation from Mass General Hospital that his autoimmune brain inflammation was thought to be caused by his vaccines YEARS earlier. His is on permanent disability. My teenage son was injured at 6 mo by the Hep B shot (based on family photos YEARS later). He now has a learning disability that affects his eyes. I was injured by a rubella shot in 2007. I figured that I had a relapse of preeclampsia AFTER giving birth, but then learned that the Rubella Vaccine is not recommended for someone suffering from PreE - This vaccine may cause AN increase in blood pressure. I should not even be here to tell me story. I should be dead. Neither doctor read the warning labels on the vaccine - the one who ordered it or the one who administered it. My Young relative died after receiving 1 vaccine at 2 mo old. It took 30 days for this child to die. Say no.

65397012
Flag this comment

amdachel said on April 16, 2011 at 6:58 PM

Hundreds of thousands of parents of autistic children report that their kids were healthy and normal until they received certain routine vaccinations. One percent of our children now have autism, including almost two percent of boys. Officials can't tell us why---the only thing they're sure of is that isn't caused by vaccines. Anne Dachel, Media editor: Age of Autism

65098497
Flag this comment

freedomthinker said on April 16, 2011 at 2:40 PM

regardless of whether or not there is a link to autism, the bigger issue is choice. parents must be able to choose the manner in which they want their children raised. i absolutely loathe religion, but i would find it unconscionable to tell a parent they couldn't raise their kid to believe anything they wanted. choice is important.

65087584
Flag this comment

lilredcv said on April 16, 2011 at 1:44 PM

The "vaccine causes autism" debate is still wide open! Poul Thorsen - the man big Pharma and our Government (CDC) used to allegedly debunk this matter - has recently been indicted on money laundering and FRAUDULENT STUDIES!!! Don't believe me? Go Google it or check out the Atlanta Business Chronicle story ran on 13 April 2011. If WA state feels that parents need this education then they should make every single parent go through the review with their doctors - after all, there are RISKS involved with the disease and there are RISKS involved with the vaccines. All parents need to know those all of those risks involved so they can make an informed decision and give an informed consent on them. Failure to do provide this education to everyone can be deemed just as medically negligent.

65084824
Flag this comment