Print
Email
Share

Schools 'relearning' how to teach boys

by JEAN ENERSEN / KING 5 News

Bio | Email | Follow: @jeanenersen

KING5.com

Posted on November 30, 2011 at 6:45 PM

Updated Thursday, Dec 1 at 7:51 AM

Walk into any pre-school and  it becomes obvious.  Girls sitting still, paying attention.  Boys fidgeting, making faces and in this environment, more likely to be misbehaving.

"He wants to fight with his friends, he wants to wrestle, why wont he just sit still?  His sister will sit still and color a lot, why doesn't he do that?" said family psychologist Dan Rubin.
 
Rubin hears that all the time.
 
"What's wrong is to force boys to be something that they're not," said Rubin.
 
He says it's important to use that "boyness," to the child's advantage.
 
"So if the boy wants to make towers, put letters on the towers.  Talk to the kid about spelling, while you do an activity.  You can't talk to him like he's a girl, girls have better verbal skills and better social skills," said Rubin.
 
Kindergarten teacher Shelley Simonsen couldn't agree more.
 
"We need to understand what boys like and are in to, so if your child is really interested in forts there are some really great books about treehouses all over the world," said Simonsen.
 
Turns out that not letting these boys run, learn, and play like boys can do more harm than good.
 
"When boys don't have appropriate rough and tumble play, they don't learn how to appropriately self regulate, they dont know the difference between play fighting and real fighting.  What we want to do is teach boys good self-regulation skills so they can sit down and pay attention when they need to," said Rubin.
 
That's crucial because boys are far more likely to flunk or drop out of school, and  five times more likely to be labeled as hyperactive.
 
The gender gap has been showing up in colleges since 2000, where up to 57 percent of the student population is now female.
 
 

Print
Email
Share
 

To add a comment, please register or login.

1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Comments: Displaying 1 - 7 of 7

domesticdiva said on December 6, 2011 at 11:13 AM

I have always thought that we should have separate classrooms for boys and girls. I think it would help. I am a survivor of bullying when I was in grade school, and i believe I would like school a lot better if I could have focused on learning. Instead of be harassed by some of the boys. I also think that maybe, boys should have male teachers. Nothing against female teachers, but I think maybe it could help. ? just an idea.

77984008
Flag this comment

intrepid1 said on December 5, 2011 at 5:53 PM

I never understood why we didn't teach alphabet and spelling in pre-school, Kindergarten and first grade on the play ground with letter grids painted on pavement or as signs posted on fences where there are games involving balls and movement tied into the letters and words being learned... takes more imagination and goes outside the paper-pencil-rote of the typical classroom. I can think of dozens of ways to engage boys, and girls, in hands on "play" with learning, but schools aren't structured to facilitate learning outside defined norms... and with additional emphasis on standardized testing, creative teaching and learning is hamstrung. Of course, the factory-like processing of schools is problematic and part of the problem.

77948937
Flag this comment

remainingreal said on December 5, 2011 at 1:55 PM

Well, listening to all this, I must have raised my three boys as girls, because they KNOW how to behave and listen and sit still in a classroom. Granted, they don't act that way at home. But there they have more freedom. I think that classroom teaching can work for the norm, but there are some students who would learn better by physical activity because they are more physical creatures. What they ought to try doing is having a wide range of ideas to get through to the various styles of learning for a kid instead of trying to cram them all into one style or teaching extremes. But our school could certainly learn something about allowing kids to have more active play time. Shoot, in our school, they aren't even allowed to play tag. How stupid is that? And people wonder why kids are getting obese? And a while back the ENTIRE second grade got talked to by the principal because some of the kids were playing pretend karate kicking at recess and it was strictly forbidden. Really?

77938842
Flag this comment

mcrain092 said on December 2, 2011 at 2:44 PM

Uhh most kids DO grow up and get "desk jobs" ... news flash! lol.

77813397
Flag this comment

btvsrcks said on December 2, 2011 at 12:57 PM

"Most kids are not going to grow up and get a desk job." This made me laugh. What are most kids going to be doing? Aren't most well educated kids going for the desk job? Personally, this whole 'boys are different' is ridiculous. Parents treat boys and girls differently, so they are socialized to be more active. If you want your child to do well in school, teach them about play time being play time and listening time being listening time. Not too big of a stretch.

77807934
Flag this comment

pnwfemale said on December 1, 2011 at 12:12 PM

Not all girls learn by sitting still and watching. Not all boys learn by doing or being active. Education should be about how best to relay information to individual girls and boys. I should add that not all teachers are capable of teaching to those students who are active learners. If students could be grouped according to how they learn best, then placed with appropriate teachers, then possibly there would be more student successes rather than frustrations.

77743644
Flag this comment

aziza said on December 1, 2011 at 7:51 AM

AT LAST! WHY do educational trends go exclusively one way or another? What really is missing is the element and importance of play. They need to move. There is nothing wrong with boys- once the educational trend required everyone to sit and be quiet, then we saw an uptick in 'hyperactivity and ADHD' diagnosis. (Not to take away from those who actually have ADHD) Does anyone realize what we are asking of kids these days in school? They are to sit still and work at a desk for SIX hours, no recess, 20min for lunch and maybe a music, PE or library class. Most kids are not going to grow up and get a desk job.

77728839
Flag this comment