Print
Email
Share

Brain infection from water amoeba kills 3; victim used 'neti pot'

Brain infection from water amoeba kills 3; victim used 'neti pot'

Brain infection from water amoeba kills 3; victim used 'neti pot'

KING5.com

Posted on August 18, 2011 at 2:55 PM

ATLANTA (AP) -- Two children and a young man have died this summer from a brain-eating amoeba that lives in water, health officials say.  The death of the young man, who was from Louisiana, was traced to water used in a neti pot.

The case is being called an unusual one by health officials, who have not identified the man or where he died.  His death in June was traced to the tap water he used in a device called a neti pot. It's a small teapot-shaped container used to rinse out the nose and sinuses with salt water to relieve allergies, colds and sinus trouble.

Health officials later found the amoeba in the home's water system. The problem was confined to the house; it wasn't found in city water samples, said Dr. Raoult Ratard, Louisiana's state epidemiologist.

The young man, who was only identified as in his 20s and from southeast Louisiana, had not been swimming nor been in contact with surface water, Ratard added.

He said only sterile, distilled, or boiled water should be used in neti pots.

This month, the rare infection also killed a 16-year-old Florida girl, who fell ill after swimming, and a 9-year-old Virginia boy, who died a week after he went to a fishing day camp. The boy had been dunked the first day of camp, his mother told the Richmond Times-Dispatch.

Those cases are consistent with past cases, which are usually kids -- often boys -- who get exposed to the bug while swimming or doing water sports in warm ponds or lakes.

The illness is extremely rare. About 120 U.S. cases -- almost all of them deaths -- have been reported since the amoeba was identified in the early 1960s, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

About three deaths are reported each year, on average. Last year, there were four.

There are no signs that cases are increasing, said Jonathan Yoder, who coordinates surveillance of waterborne diseases for the CDC

. The amoeba -- Naegleria fowleri -- gets up the nose, burrows up into the skull and destroys brain tissue. It's found in warm lakes and rivers during the hot summer months, mostly in the South.

It's a medical mystery why some people who swim in amoeba-containing water get the fatal nervous system condition while many others don't, experts say.

But the cases that do occur tend to be tragic, and there's only been one report of successful treatment.

"It's very difficult to treat. Most people die from it," Ratard said.

Print
Email
Share
 

To add a comment, please register or login.

1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Comments: Displaying 1 - 7 of 7

couchbull said on December 11, 2011 at 11:36 AM

I'm not sure why anyone would post that rinsing your sinuses with saline solution is homeopathic gibberish? It doesn't cure anything but it is very helpful to folks like me who have year-long allergies and are chronically congested. There is nothing freaky or weird about clearing out your sinuses. It's about as weird as cleaning your ears with a q-tip or brushing your teeth. And the one case where the guys died who used a neti pot - the bigger issue was why was the ameoba in their water system? I'd think you'd run the risk too with kids drinking out of the hose, or dunking their head in the bath too if it's in your household water.

78257422
Flag this comment

karae62 said on November 16, 2011 at 4:11 PM

I sure hope the folks who read the headline actually take the time to read the article. It's very misleading. I have used a neti-pot for almost 3 years now and I can't live a pain free life without it. Used properly, it relieves the worst symptoms for those of us with chronic sinusitis. If I go more than two days without using it (which I don't anymore), I get pain and pressure right between my eyes. It is a lifesaver for me! So sorry to hear about the loss of a very young life....

77044952
Flag this comment

intrepid1 said on November 3, 2011 at 7:00 PM

And this is why only sterile, distilled, or boiled water should be used in neti pots... neti pots can be effective in helping with sinus issues, but people need to follow directions and not over do it.

76366467
Flag this comment

cntbelieveit2395 said on October 19, 2011 at 6:07 AM

Wow, good job underserf. No doubt the recommendation that MD made to relieve your symptoms was a danger to your health... since ONE person died because of IMPROPER usage of the "neti pot". You did great by reporting him and by going and seeing a lawyer. Thank you for your support of our greatly inflated medical costs and for supporting the fear of MD's of being sued for trying to do their job.

75538439
Flag this comment

underserf said on August 28, 2011 at 6:33 AM

Yeah, I had an MD recommend a "neti pot" and snorting salt water (saline solution likely wouldn't support amoebic life either) to treat my raspy voice - while my regular MD was on extended vacation. Turned out to be a nodule on my lower vocal cords. I reported the character to his boss, the AMA and a local lawyer, in case the nodule was malignant. It wasn't & I got the medical clinic to post a memo telling MDs temporarily assigned to a patient (because their regular PCP is out of the clinic) to LEAVE PATIENT TREATMENT AS IS when teh pt is not their regularly seen one. This saline insufflation is about as popular as homeopathic gibberish - and about equally as effective in treating anything but excess cocaine use...

73030302
Flag this comment

stonetrails said on August 19, 2011 at 5:31 AM

stonetrails avatar

Dr. Ratard. . . giggle. . .

72591354
Flag this comment

mcd1975272738114 said on August 18, 2011 at 5:12 PM

mcd1975272738114 avatar

The two kids swimming catching that, how terribly sad. The guy using the Neti Pot......... a failure to read the directions. It is very clearly written on the box and on the saline packets to boil tap water first or use distilled water.

72572596
Flag this comment